军事知识服务平台
股东表决权拘束协议的效力研究
Research on the Validity of Shareholders' Voting Agreements:The Boundaries Between Freedom of Contract and Organizational Constraints
摘要 股东表决权拘束协议处于合同法意思自治与公司法组织强制的交汇点.在规范供给不足的背景下,司法裁判长期面临效力认定标准不一、公司利益审查缺位以及强制履行判定摇摆等困境.基于"契约—组织"双层法律关系分析框架,可对该类协议的效力与救济规则进行体系化讨论.在第一层债权关系中,应厘清私法领域的"人身泛化"逻辑误区,还原表决权作为法人财产安排工具的本质,坚守意思自治优先,确认协议的内部有效性.在第二层组织法关系中,违约救济之实际履行应置于实质审查与形式转化的双重维度下:实质层面,应以公司整体利益与股东合法权益为红线,原则上阻却表决权购买等协议的组织效力;形式层面,受制于商事外观主义,协议效力的穿透需依赖法定程序通道.据此,确立"隐蔽即赔偿,公开即执行"的裁判规则,明确协议唯有经全体股东一致同意或章程公示等形式转化,方可获得实际履行之效力,以此在维护商事创新的同时鼓励公司走向透明化治理.
Abstract:
Shareholders' voting agreements lie at the intersection of the principle of party au-tonomy under contract law and mandatory rules in corporate law.Against the deficit in normative supply,judicial practices have long faced practical dilemmas such as inconsistent standards for determining validity,the absence of corporate interest review,and wavering judgments on specif-ic performance.Contextualized within the analytical framework of"contract-organization"legal relationships,a systematic discussion of the validity and remedies for such agreements can be conducted.In the first layer(law of obligations),it is necessary to clarify the logical fallacy of"personalization"in private law,restore the property attributes of voting rights as a tool for corpo-rate ownership arrangement,and uphold the priority of party autonomy to affirm the internal valid-ity of the agreements.In the second layer(organizational law),this paper reconstructs the spe-cific performance of breach remedies through the dual dimensions of substantive review and formal conversion:Substantively,corporate interests and directors' fiduciary duties must serve as"red lines",and in principle,the organizational validity of agreements such as voting rights purchase agreements should be precluded;formally,restricted by the doctrine of commercial appearance,the piercing of contractual validity must rely on statutory procedural channels.Consequently,this paper proposes a remedial rule of"compensation for concealment,enforcement upon disclosure,"clarifying that an agreement may only take effect for actual performance if it is converted through formal through formal means,such as unanimous consent by all shareholders or public disclosure in the articles of association.This approach aims to safeguard commercial innovation while com-pelling corporate entities toward transparent governance.
刊 名 法学杂志 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 47(5)
机标分类号: D923.6 F832.5 TP391
在线出版日期: 2026年10月13日