Modeling of Grid-following and Grid-forming MMC and Comparative Analysis of Mul-ti-band Oscillation Modes
摘要
模块化多电平换流器(modular multilevel converter,MMC)在并网运行时可能引发多频段振荡问题,而不同控制策略的换流器(跟网型(grid-following,GFL)和构网型(grid-forming,GFM))对系统稳定性影响显著.该文聚焦于分析两种换流器在多频段的稳定性表现,建立系统的对比分析框架,快速扫描关键参数并识别模态迁移规律.首先,建立了在统一基准、统一 MMC 主电路参数以及统一链路延时的 GFL和 GFM 型 MMC 详细小信号模型.然后,采用"特征值分析+根轨迹"的方法对比研究了 GFL 和 GFM 型 MMC 在低频、次/超同步、中频和高频范围内的振荡模态特性;最后,揭示了两者在多频段稳定性的关键差异:GFL型MMC在低频段主要由功率外环控制主导.次/超同步段则主要取决于环流抑制和电流内环控制,而锁相环的作用相对较弱;GFM 型 MMC 虽能增强系统惯性,但其功率环与虚拟阻抗控制可能激发次/超同步和中频振荡,并且虚拟阻抗的调节呈现出明显的频段耦合效应.研究发现,电流内环控制器在两种控制策略中均在多频段中表现出高敏感性.此外,还发现电网强度降低虽有助于高频稳定却会弱化中频稳定性;控制延时过大会诱发中高频负阻尼.论文研究可为面向不同运行场景的MMC控制参数优化提供重要理论依据.
Modular multilevel converter(MMC)may cause multi-band oscillation during grid-connected operation,while converters with different control strategies,such as grid-following(GFL)and grid-forming(GFM),have a significant im-pact on system stability.This paper focuses on the analysis of the stability performance of two converters in multi-band,and establishes a comparative analysis framework of the system,quickly scanning key parameters and identifying modal transfer laws.Firstly,the detailed small-signal models of GFL and GFM MMC with unified reference,unified MMC main circuit parameters,and unified link delay are established.Then,the oscillation mode characteristics of GFL and GFM MMC in low frequency,sub/super synchronization,medium frequency and high frequency range are compared and stud-ied by using the method of'eigenvalue analysis+root locus'.Finally,the key difference between the two in multi-band stability is revealed:the GFL MMC is mainly dominated by the power outer loop control in the low frequency band.The sub/super-synchronous section mainly depends on the circulating current suppression and current inner loop control,while the role of the phase-locked loop is relatively weak.Although the GFM-type MMC can enhance the system inertia,its power loop and virtual impedance control may excite sub/super-synchronization and intermediate frequency oscillation,and the adjustment of virtual impedance shows an obvious frequency band coupling effect.It is found that the current in-ner loop controller shows high sensitivity in multi-band in both control strategies.In addition,it is also found that the reduction of power grid strength contributes to high-frequency stability but weakens medium-frequency stability;exces-sive control delay will induce medium-and high-frequency negative damping.The research in this paper can provide an important theoretical basis for the optimization of MMC control parameters for different operating scenarios.