From Machine Replacement to Human-Machine Symbiosis:Case Study on the Mechanisms of the Symbiotic Evolutionary Process of Human-Machine Hybrid Workforce in Traditional Manufacturing Enterprises
摘要
传统制造企业如何破解"既要机器换人、又要人机共生"的结构性矛盾,进而将新引入的机器与既有员工整合成为共生共创的人机混合劳动力队伍,这已成为"人工智能+制造"行动下亟待解决的重要议题.然而,现有文献中"换人"与共生的二元对立逻辑以及线性演化论,均不足以深刻描绘这一复杂图景.基于正泰案例,本文将机器视作与员工并肩协作共生的劳动行动主体,以共生理论和价值共生论作为理论基础,聚焦"传统制造企业人机混合劳动力的共生演化过程机制"这一核心议题开展纵向单案例研究.本文主要有以下研究发现.(1)人机混合劳动力的共生演化过程存在关系演化与价值演化两种主导逻辑,且非对称特性所引致的异步性缺口促使其形成双轮交替循环、彼此触发的异步联动,进而将"机器换人"与人机共生缝合为共生演化过程的一体两翼.(2)关系演化主导逻辑旨在揭示从"机器换人"走向阶段性人机共生的演化过程,该过程侧重关系张力所触发的关系结构重塑,涉及操作、动力、控制功能乃至智能主体等多层次的人机分工迭代,以及"人机料法产环"多要素的重构.(3)价值演化主导逻辑旨在揭示企业打破阶段性人机共生稳态并走向更高阶"机器换人"的演化过程,且需历经能力跃升、行动跃升、价值跃升等多次跃升;该过程涉及业务能力、行动效益、价值增益等需求牵引以激活新需求和价值缺口,以及赋能、协同、共生等价值迭代以触发价值重心升级.(4)价值演化过程的阶段性"回落"并非简单"退化",而是蛰伏蓄能后的价值范式跃迁,这也凸显了人机混合劳动力的共生演化过程的非线性特征.本文构建了人机混合劳动力的共生演化模型并打开了演化过程"黑箱",实践上可为传统制造企业破解"换人"与共生双重课题、打造智能经济新形态并培育工业新质生产力提供经验借鉴,理论上可为深化探究人机混合劳动力的共生演化奠定理论基础.
Under the"AI+Manufacturing"initiative,traditional manufacturing enterprises(TMEs)are facing a structural paradox between machine replacement and human-machine symbiosis.Navigating this paradox and integrating newly introduced machines with incumbent employees into a symbiotic human-machine hybrid workforce has become a pressing issue.However,the prevailing literature,grounded in a dualistic logic of machine replacement and human-machine symbiosis and a linear evolutionary perspective,offers limited insights into the complexity and dynamism of this transformation.Taking CHINT Electric Co.,Ltd.as a typical case,this study conceptualizes machines as active workforce actors working alongside humans.Grounded in symbiosis theory and value symbiosis theory,this study adopts a longitudinal single-case approach to unpack the symbiotic evolutionary process of human-machine hybrid workforce within TMEs.The research findings are as follows.First,the symbiotic evolutionary process of the human-machine hybrid workforce is driven by two dominant logics:relational evolution and value evolution.The asynchronous gap arising from their asymmetric characteristics fosters an alternating dual-wheel cycle and a mutually triggering linkage,effectively stitching machine replacement and human-machine symbiosis together as two interdependent facets of a unified symbiotic evolutionary process.Second,the dominant logic of relational evolution elucidates the evolutionary trajectory from machine replacement to phased human-machine symbiosis.This process centers on the structural reshaping of symbiotic relationships triggered by relational tension,entailing multi-level iterations of human-machine division of labor-spanning operational,motivational,and control functions,as well as the roles of intelligent agents.Furthermore,it involves the reconfiguration of multiple elements,specifically encompassing humans,machines,materials,methods,products,and environments.Third,the dominant logic of value evolution explains how TMEs move beyond the steady state of phased human-machine symbiosis and evolve toward advanced machine replacement.This process unfolds through successive leaps in capability,action,and value creation.Meanwhile,this process is driven by organizational demands for business capability enhancement,action efficiency improvement,and value gain amplification,which activate emergent needs and value gaps.It is further reinforced by iterative cycles of empowerment,collaboration,and symbiosis that collectively trigger an upward shift in the system's value center.Fourth,the phased fallback observed in the value evolution process does not signify simple regression.Rather,it represents a value paradigm transition following a phase of capability accumulation,highlighting the nonlinear nature of symbiotic evolution.This study develops a symbiotic evolutionary model of human-machine hybrid workforce,thereby unpacking the black box of its underlying evolutionary process.Practically,the findings provide actionable insights for TMEs to navigate the structural paradox between machine replacement and human-machine symbiosis,while forging new modalities of the intelligent economy and cultivating new quality industrial productive forces.Theoretically,this study provides a foundational framework for advancing scholarly inquiry into the symbiotic evolution of human-machine hybrid workforce.