军事知识服务平台
论个人信息删除权与侵权请求权并行下的竞合与理论修正
The Concurrent Operation and Theoretical Revision of the Right to Delete Personal Information and the Right to Seek forInfringement Remedies
摘要 我国对个人信息的删除保护因历史原因形成了个人信息删除权与侵权请求权并行的样态,从各权利的性质及功能定位等分析看,其实质上是人格权请求权与侵权请求权的并行.依法体系和规范保护目的要求,不能也没有必要限制排除侵权请求权的适用,该两权利协调配合更有助于实现个人信息删除保护.基于竞合构成和竞合实益的规范分析,即便两权利性质不同,仍能认定为竞合而不是聚合.其判断标准是"同一原因事实上的请求内容同一(而非标的、目的)+禁止重复履行(实益)".两请求权发生竞合时,传统竞合理论对"删除规范的整体关系、规范目的等"的认定存在缺陷,不宜作为直接处理范式.此时,可基于"两请求权的性质/作用及竞合样态""特定法规范保护目的、当事人间的利益平衡",结合"概念体系的逻辑演绎""法律解释与利益衡量"等方法,修正请求权相互影响说以适用.无论采何种请求权证成删除请求,各自在构成认定、行使限制、可处分性等方面均得互相影响.
Abstract:
China's legal protection for the erasure of personal information has developed into coexistence of the right to erasure and tort claims.Analysis based on the nature and function of these rights reveals that they essentially represent the parallel existence of the claims for personality rights and tort claims.According to the requirements of the legal system and the protective purpose of the clauses,it is neither possible nor necessary to restrict or exclude the application of the tort claims.Based on a normative analysis of the elements and benefits of concurrence,even though the nature of these two rights differs,they can still be recognized as concurrence of claims rather than aggregation.The judging critera lie in two dimensions:identical claim contents arising from the same factual cause(rather than identical subject matter or purpose),plus the rule against duplicate performance.When these two claims concur,traditional theories such as the concurrence theory of norms or the concurrence theory of claims suffer from the defect of"misjudging the overall relationship between the erasure norms and their protective purposes",making them difficult to apply directly.Therefore,considering the specific manifestation and essence of this concurrence,and employing methods such as interest balancing,value judgment,and logical deduction,the concurrence theory of interactive claims can be adapted for application after some adjustments.Regardless of the approach adopted to justify the erasure claim,the concurring claims mutually influence each other in aspects such as the constitutive elements,statutes of limitation,limitations of liability,and the disposition of rights.
刊 名 河北法学 PKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 44(9)
分类号: DF52
机标分类号: D924.32 C912.63 U441
在线出版日期: 2026年10月28日
基金项目: 22AFX015:国家社会科学基金,