The Labor Law Construction of the Right to Request Human Intervention in Algorithmic Decision-Making
摘要
在算法技术广泛应用的背景下,劳动者因自动化决策而面临救济途径不足的问题.为此,在劳动法中引入"人工干预请求权",可作为现有救济体系的重要补充,以应对算法管理可能带来的新型权益风险.通过分析算法管理中的侵权类型、考察算法在人力资源管理中的实际应用,并界定该权利在数字环境下的适用范围,可论证将其纳入劳动法体系的必要性、可行性与合理性.在具体制度设计上,可借鉴欧盟《一般数据保护条例》(GDPR)中有关人工干预的规定及其成员国的实施经验,以比例原则为基础,明确权利主体、义务内容与行使条件;通过建立最低程序保障、双重申诉机制与三重救济渠道,在算法效率与劳动者权益之间取得平衡;同时推动该权利与现有劳动法律制度、算法备案监管及可信人工智能技术相衔接,确保其能够切实、有序地适用于劳动关系实践.
Against the backdrop of the widespread application of algorithmic technology,workers face insufficient avenues for redress when subjected to automated decision-making.To address this,introducing a"right to request human intervention"into labor law can serve as a crucial supplement to the existing relief system,countering the novel risks to rights and interests potentially arising from algorithmic management.By analyzing the types of infringements within algorithmic management,examining the practical application of algorithms in human resource management,and defining the scope of this right's applicability in the digital environment,the necessity,feasibility,and rationality of incorporating it into the labor law system can be demonstrated.Regarding specific institutional design,reference can be made to the provisions concerning human intervention in the EU's General Data Protection Regulation(GDPR)and the implementation experiences of its member states.Based on the principle of proportionality,the subjects of the right,the content of obligations,and the conditions for its exercise should be clarified.A balance between algorithmic efficiency and workers' rights can be achieved by establishing minimum procedural safeguards,a dual complaint mechanism,and a triple relief channel.Simultaneously,efforts should be made to integrate this right with existing labor law institutions,algorithmic filing and supervision,and trustworthy artificial intelligence technology,ensuring its practical and orderly application in labor relations practice.