反不正当竞争法视阈下生成式AI模仿行为的正当性判定
The Legitimacy Determination of Generative AI Imitation Behavior under the Perspective of the Anti-Unfair Competition Law
摘要
生成式AI的模仿功能是引发生成式AI侵犯知识产权法律争议的重要源头之一.由于知识产权法保护范围有限,常作为知识产权法补充的《反不正当竞争法》,可能会成为判定模仿行为合法性的重要法律依据.理论上,生成式AI模仿行为可能构成混淆、不正当获取使用数据等不正当竞争行为,但司法实践在《反不正当竞争法》对知识产权补充保护限度,模仿自由原则适用规范与边界,以及一般条款中搭便车理论适用等方面的争议,将会给生成式AI模仿行为的正当性判定带来严峻挑战.为此,须对《反不正当竞争法》就知识产权所提供的补充保护设置限制;通过立法明确模仿自由原则的适用条件与论证逻辑;最终,应明确基于"恶意"不正当搭便车行为中的过错认定标准,并规范竞争效果分析中的多方利益衡量.
The imitation function of generative artificial intelligence is one of the main reasons for intellectual property disputes.Due to the protection scope of Intellectual Property Law is limited,the Anti-Unfair Competition Law which serves as supplement of intellectual property,may become a important legal basis for determining the legitimacy of imitation behavior.Generative AI imitation behavior could constitute unfair competition such as confusion,unfair acquisition or use of data,etc.However,the legitimacy determination of generative ai imitation behavior will pose challenges because of the disagreements in judicial practice,regarding to the disagreement with the limits of supplementary protection of the Anti-Unfair Competition Law to the Intellectual Property Law,the application and boundaries of the freedom to imitate,and the applicability of the"Free-Riding"theory.Therefore,set limits on the supplementary protection provided by the Anti-Unfair Competition Law for Intellectual Property Law;clarify the conditions for applying the freedom to imitate and its limitation;finally,establish clear fault standards for malicious free-riding behavior and normalize the balancing of multiple interests in competition effect analysis.
年,卷(期):
2026, 44(9)
分类号:
DF414
机标分类号:
D923.4
TP393.09
F274
在线出版日期:
2026年10月28日
基金项目:
21BFX100:国家社会科学基金23YJZX41YB:浙江省哲学社会科学规划课题,