摘要
推定在当前刑事诉讼中受到重视,但其方法的界定与适用存在较大分歧.为弥合分歧,且考虑推定问题的复杂性,可将推定分为典型与非典型两种类型.典型推定的基本特征是对基础事实与待证事实之间的"中间事实"应证不证,产生证明过程的"中断"与"跳跃",导致证明标准降低(但维系"心证"标准),并因之转移证明责任;非典型推定也具有通过基础事实推导案件事实且允许反证的形式特征,但并无明显证明"中断",不降低或基本不降低证明标准,也不必然导致证明责任转移.除证明链条较单薄,推断力可能略弱外,与一般依靠间接事实推论并无根本区别."特征行为认定法"系非典型推定,"明知"等主观要素判断的基本方法应是"综合认定法",如采用"特征行为认定法",也不应脱离"综合认定"框架,且应注意证据法上明知程度与刑法中明知内容的区别,"明知可能"不得理解为"可能明知".总体要求是坚守底线共识,慎用刑事推定.
Presumption has attracted increasing attention in contemporary criminal procedure,but substantial disagreement remains regarding its definition and application.To reconcile these differences and account for the complexity of presumption,this article classifies presumption into typical presumption and atypical presumption.Typical presumption is characterized by the failure to prove the intermediate fact linking the basic fact and the fact to be proved,thereby creating an interruption and leap in the process of proof.This results in a reduced standard of proof(while maintaining the standard of inner conviction)and consequently shifts the burden of proof.Atypical presumption also shares the formal characteristics of inferring the fact in issue from basic facts and permitting rebuttal.However,it does not involve any significant interruption in the process of proof,does not reduce(or only minimally reduces)the standard of proof,and does not necessarily shift the burden of proof.Apart from a relatively less robust chain of proof and a potentially weaker inferential force,it is not fundamentally different from ordinary inference based on indirect facts.The characteristic-conduct approach constitutes atypical presumption.With respect to determining subjective elements such as knowing,the appropriate method is the comprehensive assessment approach.Even where the characteristic-conduct approach is employed,it should remain within the framework of comprehensive assessment.Moreover,attention should be paid to the distinction between the degree of knowing in the evidence law and the content of knowing in the substantive criminal law:Knowing possibility should not be understood as possibly knowing.Overall,the guiding principle is to adhere to the minimum consensus and exercise caution in the use of criminal presumption.