军事知识服务平台
论数智分析作为法律方法
摘要 数智分析越来越多地被运用于各国的司法实践.在我国,相关运用尤其活跃并受人瞩目.在一定意义上,它业已全方位地影响和重塑着法官思维,使得我国司法正处于数智分析参与其中的迭代升级中.如果把重塑后的司法定位为数智裁判,可以认为智慧体的角色就是司法主体,进而存在一种AI法官;如果把智慧体的参与定位于辅助司法,则其在司法中的角色主要是法律方法,是法官的重要思维伙伴,并以法律方法的身份,深度参与到司法的传统方法——法律解释、法律推理、法律论证、利益衡量、法律续造中.所以,智慧体辅助司法裁判是其作为法律方法的前提所在.数智分析作为法律方法,不是对传统法律方法的替代,而是升级.两相比较,其特征是综合性、复合性、中立性、客观性和效率性.对于数智分析作为法律方法在司法中的作用,学界有不同的看法.但其推动司法迭代、重塑司法、超越既有法律方法,并最终助力实现司法正义的功能,已是不争的事实.
Abstract:
Digital and intelligent analysis(DIA)is increasingly being applied in judicial practice across various countries.In China,its application has attracted considerable attention:it has comprehensively engaged with,influenced and reshaped the judiciary and the mindset of judges,resulting in the Chinese judicial system undergoing iterative upgrades driven by DIA.If we define the reshaped judiciary as"digital and intelligent adjudication",we might regard the"intelligent entity"as the judicial subject,thereby positing the existence of an"AI judge".If,however,we define the participation of the intelligent entity as"judicial assistance",its role in the judicial process is primarily that of legal methods-a vital intellectual partner to judges-meaning it engages deeply in the judicial process through legal methods:legal interpretation,legal reasoning,legal argumentation,balancing of interests,and legal creation.Consequently,the intelligent system's role in assisting judicial adjudication is a prerequisite for its function as legal methods.As legal methods,the DIA does not replace traditional legal methods but rather upgrades them.When compared,its characteristics are comprehensiveness,complexity,neutrality,objectivity and efficiency.There are differing views within academia regarding the role of the DIA as legal methods in the judicial process.However,it is already a fact that it leads to the iteration and reshaping of the judiciary,transcends existing legal methods,and ultimately contributes to the realisation of judicial justice.
刊 名 交大法学 PKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (5)
机标分类号: D90 B81-05 F272
在线出版日期: 2026年9月29日