军事知识服务平台
加密货币刑法属性界定的"三层次"审查
摘要 在刑法理论及实务中,能否将加密货币认定为财物的问题仍存在较大争议.基于法秩序统一性原理,此问题不是一个纯粹的刑法学问题,在分析时必须经过前置行政法、民法和刑法本体的"三层次"审查.对于加密货币的法律属性及相关业务行为的认定,行政法判断主要从维护金融稳定的行政监管角度出发,将加密货币界定为可能影响经济金融秩序并需要严格监管的因素.但是,相关规定实际上均未否定加密货币的财产属性或者判定其不属于财物.民法判断中,虽然加密货币不是我国《民法典》规定的物权客体,但是物与财产并非完全对应,不论是民法中的财产还是刑法中的财产,均要大于"物"的范围,因而也不能据此认定其不属于刑法中的财物.廓清前置法的真实影响后可见,将加密货币认定为财物实际并不存在前置法障碍.而从刑法本体视角,加密货币符合财产概念的内在要求,且不属于违禁物,世界主要经济体也大多将其规定为特殊的财产类型.因此,有充分理由将加密货币认定为刑法中一种新的财产类型.
Abstract:
There remains considerable controversy in criminal law theory and practice over whether cryptocurrency can be recognized as property.Based on the principle of the unity of legal order,this issue is not purely a criminal law matter and requires a three-stage review of administrative law,civil law and criminal law itself.In characterizing cryptocurrency's legal attributes and related business activities,administrative law,from the perspective of safeguarding financial stability,defines it as a factor requiring strict regulation due to potential risks to the economic and financial order,but relevant provisions do not negate its proprietary attribute or exclude it from property.From the civil law perspective,although cryptocurrency is not an object of real rights under China's Civil Code,property in both civil and criminal law is broader than"things",so it cannot be denied as criminal law property.Clarifying prepositive laws shows no obstacles to recognizing cryptocurrency as property.Moreover,cryptocurrency meets the inherent requirements of criminal law property,is not a prohibited article,and is generally regarded as special property by major global economies.Thus,there are sufficient grounds to recognize it as a new type of criminal law property.
刊 名 交大法学 PKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (5)
机标分类号: D923.2 TS664.01 F830
在线出版日期: 2026年9月29日
基金项目: 22CFX063:国家社会科学基金,