军事知识服务平台
超越"非公即私":公共数据授权运营的性质辨析及其司法化解
摘要 公共数据授权运营同时具有配置公共资源、实现公共管理目标和引入市场机制开发利用数据等多重功能,其法律性质的明晰不仅关系到公共数据资源的配置方式,也关系到运营主体权利义务的确定及相关纠纷的司法救济.既有公法定性说、私法定性说与复合性质说虽分别揭示了授权运营的不同面向,但仍未系统解决具体争议中公私法关系的识别、衔接及其程序配置问题.公共数据授权运营法律性质的讨论,最终应落实到具体争议的程序选择、审查对象、规范适用和裁判方式.为此,应当由整体制度的抽象定性转向具体争议的类型化识别,将公共数据授权运营纠纷区分为授权决定纠纷、协议订立纠纷、协议履行纠纷与数据交易纠纷.针对这些不同纠纷类型,采取以行政诉讼为主导、相关民事争议一并审理的程序路径,并根据具体法律关系分别适用公法规范与私法规范,配置差异化的审查标准和裁判方式,从而兼顾公共数据安全与公平配置、运营主体信赖利益及市场交易安全.
Abstract:
The authorized operation of public data encompasses multiple dimensions,including the allocation of public resources,the achievement of public administration objectives,and the introduction of market mechanisms for the development and utilization of data.Clarifying its legal nature concerns not only the manner in which public data resources are allocated but also the determination of the rights and obligations of operating entities and the judicial remedies available for related disputes.Existing public-law,private-law,and composite-characterization theories have each revealed certain aspects of the authorized operation of public data,but they have yet to provide a systematic solution to the identification and coordination of public-and private-law relationships,or to the allocation of procedural mechanisms,in specific disputes.The discussion of the legal nature of the authorized operation of public data should ultimately serve to determine the appropriate judicial procedure,object of review,applicable legal norms,and form of adjudication.Accordingly,the analytical focus should shift from the abstract characterization of the system as a whole to the typological identification of specific disputes,classifying disputes arising from the authorized operation of public data into those concerning authorization decisions,the conclusion of authorized-operation agreements,the performance of such agreements,and data transactions.These different types of disputes should be addressed through a procedural framework in which administrative litigation serves as the primary avenue and related civil disputes may be adjudicated together.Public-and private-law norms should be applied respectively according to the specific legal relationship involved,with differentiated standards of review and forms of adjudication.This approach can balance public data security and equitable allocation,the protection of operating entities' reliance interests,and the security of market transactions.
刊 名 交大法学 PKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (5)
机标分类号: D912.6 D630.8 G647
在线出版日期: 2026年9月29日
基金项目: 24ZDA025:国家社会科学基金2024TSG08102:清华大学文科建设双高计划创新方向建设专项智能时代个人数据法律体系研究项目,