Research on Appropriate Ecological Flow for the Source of Nanpan River Based on Multiple Hydrological and Hydraulic Methods
摘要
南盘江是我国第三大河流珠江的源头,为了计算南盘江源头的生态流量,并确定适宜的生态流量计算方法,基于沾益水文站1954-2021年天然月径流和1978-2023年实测日流量数据,分析了南盘江源头水文情势.采用逐月频率法、R2-Cross法、Qp法、Tennant法、逐月Tennant法、湿周法和生态水力半径法等7种水文水力学方法计算南盘江源头生态流量.为了对比分析7种方法的优劣,基于适应指数和满足程度2个指标,建立了生态流量综合系数,综合评价河流的适宜生态流量.研究表明:①南盘江源头年径流量总体呈下降趋势,年际变化明显.月径流年内分配不均,丰枯变化明显;最大3月、最小3月平均径流量分别占年径流量的比例为53.3%、7.6%,最大3月出现最多月份为8、9、10月,最小3月出现最多月份为3、4、5月;②通过生态流量适宜性评价,Tennant法和Qp法综合系数最高,依次为1.05和1.03.进一步结合满足程度和与水文情势规律符合程度来看,推荐Tennant法计算结果作为南盘江源头沾益水文站的适宜生态流量;③推荐Tennant法计算生态流量汛期(6-10月)为2.34 m3/s、枯期(11-次年5月)0.78 m3/s.长系列实测日流量枯期满足程度仅为74%,与国家要求的90%还有一定差距.为提高区域生态流量达标率和保护生态环境,建议枯期采取外流域调水措施,置换区域生产生活用水,退还河道生态水量.
The Nanpan River is the source of the Pearl River,the third largest river in China.To assess the ecological flow for the source of the Nanpan River and identify a suitable calculation approach,this study analyzed the hydrological characteristics for the source of Nanpan River based on natural monthly runoff data(1954-2021)and measured daily flow data(1978-2023)from the Zhanyi Hydrological Station.Seven hydrological and hydraulic methods—namely,the monthly frequency method,R2-Cross method,Qp method,Tennant method,monthly Tennant method,wet perimeter method,and ecological hydraulic radius method—were employed to compute the ecological flow.To compare and evaluate the advantages and limitations of these methods,an ecological flow comprehensive coefficient was established based on two indicators:the adaptation index and the satisfaction degree.This coefficient was used to comprehensively assess the suitable ecological flow for the river.The findings are as follows:①Annual monthly runoff distribution is highly uneven,with pronounced fluctuations between wet and dry periods.The 3-month maximum and minimum runoff volumes account for 53.3%and 7.6%of the annual total,respectively.The months with the highest frequency of occurrence for the maximum 3-month period are August,September,and October,while those for the minimum 3-month period are March,April,and May;② Based on the suitability evaluation of ecological flows,the Tennant method and the Qp method yield the highest comprehensive coefficients,at 1.05 and 1.03,respectively.After further considering the satisfaction degree and consistency with hydrological patterns,the Tennant method is recommended for determining the suitable ecological flow at the Zhanyi Hydrological Station in the source of Nanpan Rive;③The recommended ecological flows are 2.34 m³/s for the flood season(June-October)and 0.78 m³/s for the dry season(November-May of the following year).The satisfaction degree of the long‑term measured daily flow during the dry season is 74%,which remains below the nationally required threshold of 90%.To improve regional ecological flow compliance,measures such as inter‑basin water transfers are recommended to supplement local water supply for production and domestic use,thereby restoring ecological water volumes to the river during dry periods.