军事知识服务平台
预聘—长聘制中人事退出机制的功能检视与完善
Functional Review and Refinement of the Personnel Exit Mechanism in the Tenure—Track System
摘要 预聘—长聘制以聘期考核为基本机制,将高校教师的续聘、晋升与退出纳入周期性评价过程,成为当前高校教师人事退出制度化运行的重要形式,也在一定程度上打破了传统人事管理中"能进不能出"的固化格局.当前实践中,考核标准、退出程序与救济渠道三个环节均存在明显缺陷,影响制度的正当性和规范运行.究其原因,预聘—长聘制在本土运行中逐渐偏重筛选淘汰功能,而保障学术判断独立、限制高校单方裁量、保障教师程序参与和权利救济的制度条件并未随之完善.对此,应从考核依据、决定程序和权利救济三个方面加以回应.在考核依据上,引入代表作评价机制,并保持聘期内考核标准的相对稳定;在决定程序上,完善告知、陈述申辩和解聘审批等程序要求,避免考核结论直接转化为退出决定;在权利救济上,增强校内申诉机制的独立性,完善校内分流安置与再就业支持,并进一步畅通校外救济渠道.如此,该制度才能在保有竞争功能的同时,为教师提供切实可行的权益保障.
Abstract:
The tenure-track system,with periodic contract-based evaluation as its core mechanism,in-corporates the reappointment,promotion,and exit of university faculty into a cyclical assessment process.It has thus become a significant institutionalized form of personnel exit in higher education and has,to a certain extent,broken the rigid pattern of"permanent employment"that previously character-ized traditional personnel management.In current practice,however,notable deficiencies persist in three critical aspects—evaluation criteria,exit procedures,and remedy channels—which undermine the system's legitimacy and undermine its normative operation.The underlying cause lies in the fact that,in its local implementation,the tenure-track system has increasingly gravitated towards a screening and elimina-tion function,while the institutional conditions necessary to safeguard the independence of academic judgment,to constrain the unilateral discretion of universities,and to guarantee faculty members' proce-dural participation and right remedies have not been developed commensurately.In response,improve-ments should be pursued along three dimensions:with respect to evaluation criteria,a representative works assessment mechanism should be introduced,and the assessment standards should remain relative-ly stable throughout the contract period;with respect to decision-making procedures,procedural re-quirements such as timely notification,opportunity for statements and defenses,and approval for dismiss-al should be refined,so as to prevent assessment outcomes from being directly converted into exit deci-sions;with respect to right remedies,the independence of internal appeal mechanisms should be strengthened,internal reassignment and re-employment support should be enhanced,and external rem-edy channels should be further facilitated.Only through these measures can the system retain its competi-tive function while providing faculty members with practicable and effective protection of their rights.
刊 名 江苏高教 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (9)
分类号: G647
机标分类号: C916 F832.48 D922.287
在线出版日期: 2026年10月15日