Research on the Differences and Governance Logic of Provincial Government Attention Allocation to Education,Science and Technology,and Talent:A Textual Analysis of the"15th Five—Year Plan"Outlines of 31 Provinces
摘要
教育、科技、人才一体化推进是"十五五"时期重塑区域发展动能和治理体系的重要议题.省级政府如何在规划文本中配置三者注意力,不仅反映地方对中央战略的响应程度,也折射出教育、科技、人才能否由并列部署走向系统协同.基于31个省份"十五五"规划纲要,运用锚定相关解释模型识别政策主题,从语义结构层面揭示主题的内容分布与关联特征,并从区域差异层面比较省域与板块的注意力配置格局.研究发现,省级政府在教育、科技、人才领域的注意力配置呈现科技分化最突出、教育与人才次之的格局,教育类主题在主题共现网络中的中心性低于科技和人才类主题,尚未充分发挥连接科技与人才的枢纽作用,存在形式上整体部署、实质上领域分置的倾向.上述差异根植于三重治理逻辑:人才议题的联结功能使人才成为政策关注集聚点;制度约束差异导致科技领域因约束较弱而分化最突出,教育领域虽约束较强但执行差异仍大;地方政府基于资源禀赋与发展阶段的战略适应塑造板块间的差异化注意力重心与均衡度的非线性特征.推进教育科技人才一体化,应从追求三类议题的比例均衡转向强化教育对创新与人才体系的支撑功能,形成分类推进的一体化治理机制.
The integrated advancement of education,science and technology,and talent constitutes a critical issue for reshaping regional development dynamics and governance systems during the 15th Five-Year Plan period.How provincial governments allocate their attention to these three domains in planning documents not only reflects local responsiveness to central strategies but also indicates whether educa-tion,science and technology,and talent can progress from parallel deployment toward systemic synergy.Based on the 15th Five-Year Plan outlines of 31 provinces,this study employs the Anchored CorEx model to identify policy topics,reveals the content distribution and associative characteristics of these topics at the semantic-structural level,and compares provincial and regional attention allocation patterns from the perspective of spatial disparities.The findings reveal that provincial attention allocation exhibits the most pronounced differentiation in science and technology,followed by education and talent.Education-related topics demonstrate lower degree centrality in the topic co-occurrence network compared to science and technology and talent topics,indicating that education has yet to fully play its pivotal role in connecting science and technology with talent,with a tendency toward comprehensive deployment in form but fragmented implementation in substance.These disparities are rooted in three governance log-ics:the connective function of talent issues positions talent as a focal point of policy attention;variations in institutional constraints lead to the most pronounced differentiation in science and technology where constraints are weaker,while education,though subject to stronger institutional constraints,still exhibits considerable implementation variation;and local governments' strategic adaptation based on resource endowments and development stages shapes both regionally differentiated attention centers and the nonlinear characteristics of equilibrium.To advance the integration of education,science and technolo-gy,and talent,policy efforts should shift from pursuing proportional balance among the three domains to strengthening education's supportive function for innovation and talent systems,thereby establishing a tiered governance mechanism for integrated development.