军事知识服务平台
西式民主制度加剧经济不平等的机理探析
An Analysis of the Mechanisms Through Which Western-Style Democratic Systems Exacerbate Economic Inequality
摘要 西方主流理论长期认为政治民主与经济平等之间存在相互促进的共生关系,然而20世纪后期以来诸多国家的政治转型经验表明,以建立西式民主制度为核心的政治变革并未普遍带来经济平等,反而在许多国家拉大了贫富差距.理论与现实的这一背离,需要从政治转型的内在逻辑中寻找解释.在比较政治学的视野下,基于经济自由化改革、权力资源分配与国家能力三条理论脉络,可以构建一个系统分析框架,提炼导致不平等结构的三条机制:西式民主制度的建立普遍诱发自由化导向的经济改革,在市场机会扩张的同时加剧了收入分配的失衡;转型未能促进权力资源的均等化,精英反而凭借资源、动员等方面的优势,在新制度框架内俘获政策过程;转型往往伴随着国家能力的弱化,限制了国家对市场初次分配结果的纠偏能力.要克服分配治理困境,需超越片面的制度形式更迭,在提升政府实质回应性的同时推进治理能力建设,构建更具包容性的分配秩序.
Abstract:
Mainstream Western theory has long asserted a mutually reinforcing,symbiotic relationship between political democracy and economic equality.However,political transformation experiences across numerous countries since the late 20th century demonstrate that political reforms centered on establishing Western-style democratic systems have failed to generate widespread economic equality,instead widening the wealth gap in many nations.This divergence between theory and reality necessitates an explanation derived from the internal logic of political transformation.Within comparative political science,a systematic analytical framework built upon three theoretical strands—economic liberalization reforms,power-resource distribution,and state capacity—distills three mechanisms generating structural inequality:the establishment of Western-style democratic systems universally induces liberalization-oriented economic reforms,expanding market opportunities while exacerbating income distribution imbalances;transformations fail to equalize power resources,enabling elites to leverage advantages in resources and mobilization to capture policy processes within new institutional frameworks;and transformations frequently entail the weakening of state capacity,constraining the state's ability to correct primary market distribution outcomes.Overcoming distribution governance dilemmas requires transcending superficial institutional replacements,enhancing substantive governmental responsiveness while fostering governance capacity construction,and constructing a more inclusive distributional order.
刊 名 江苏社会科学 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (4)
机标分类号: F124 R692.5 D63
在线出版日期: 2026年8月27日
基金项目: 25ZHC030:江苏省社会科学基金青年项目,