军事知识服务平台
公平竞争审查与合法性审查的关系厘定及制度协同
Relationship Clarification and Institutional Coordination Between Fair Competition Review and Legality Review
摘要 作为纵深推进全国统一大市场建设的两大关键制度工具,公平竞争审查与合法性审查的关系定位与制度协同,已成为影响全国统一大市场建设成效与两大制度未来走向的重要理论问题.基于制度、标准、程序三个维度开展分析,得出公平竞争审查独立于合法性审查的基本结论.对于公平竞争审查,应在制度上回归"评估"本质,在标准上引入本身违法原则与合理原则的分析范式,在程序上将其定位为合法性审查的前置程序.由此,在确保公平竞争审查制度独立运行的基础上,实现其与合法性审查的有效协同.
Abstract:
As two key institutional instruments for advancing the construction of a unified national market,the relationship and coordination between fair competition review and legality review have become a significant theoretical issue that affects the effectiveness of building a unified national market and the future direction of both systems.To clearly define their relationship,a three-dimensional theoretical analysis framework—encompassing institutions,standards,and procedures—can be constructed,leading to the fundamental conclusion that the fair competition review is independent of the legality review.Fair competition review should return to its essential nature of"assessment"at the institutional level,introduce the analytical paradigms of per se illegal and the rule of reason at the standard level,and be positioned as a prior procedure to legality review at the procedural level.In this way,on the basis of ensuring the independent operation of the fair competition review system,its effective coordination with legality review can be achieved.
刊 名 江苏社会科学 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (4)
机标分类号: D922.294 H059 F120
在线出版日期: 2026年8月27日