Energy consumption analysis of methanol production via coal-water slurry and pulverized coal gasification
摘要
煤制甲醇是我国甲醇生产的主要途径,煤气化作为煤化工行业的核心技术,其工艺选择对系统能耗有着重要影响.借助Aspen Plus 过程模拟软件,以生产吨甲醇的综合能耗为指标,建立了多喷嘴水煤浆气化和多喷嘴粉煤气化制甲醇全流程的工艺模型,在保持两种气化工艺的气化条件、变换气的H2与CO的物质的量比、净化气规格和所生产精甲醇规格一致的条件下,分析了全流程的综合能耗,并进一步探究了氧煤比(质量比)和气化压力对两种气化工艺制甲醇过程吨甲醇能耗的影响.结果表明:水煤浆气化工艺的吨甲醇综合能耗为1 254.57 kgce(千克标准煤),粉煤气化工艺的吨甲醇综合能耗为1 310.51 kgce,两者相差4.46%,主要归因于水煤浆气化所配套的变换装置回收的潜热更多;随着氧煤比提高,两种气化工艺的全流程吨甲醇能耗均先降后升,存在氧煤比的最佳值,水煤浆气化的最佳氧煤比约为0.78,粉煤气化的最佳氧煤比约为0.66,在最佳氧煤比的工况下,水煤浆与粉煤气化工艺的全流程吨甲醇能耗分别为1 227.53 kgce和1 242.43 kgce;随着气化压力的提高,两种气化工艺的全流程吨甲醇能耗逐渐降低,具体来看,当气化压力从2.7 MPa升高至8.7 MPa时,水煤浆气化工艺的吨甲醇能耗由1 286.62 kgce降至1 235.77 kgce,降幅为3.95%,粉煤气化工艺的吨甲醇能耗由1 359.89 kgce降至1 298.88 kgce,降幅为4.54%.
Coal-to-methanol is the primary methanol production route in China.Gasification,as the core technology of the coal chemical industry,significantly affects system energy consumption.Using Aspen Plus,process models were established for the entire methanol production based on multi-burner coal-water slurry gasification and multi-burner pulverized coal gasification,with overall energy consumption per ton of methanol as the evaluation indicator.Under consistent conditions for both gasification processes-including gasification parameters,the H2/CO ratio of the shifted syngas,purified syngas specifications,and the final refined methanol product specifications-the overall energy consumption of the entire process was analyzed.Furthermore,the effects of the oxygen/coal ratio and gasification pressure on the energy consumption per ton of methanol were investigated.The results indicate that the overall energy consumption for the coal-water slurry gasification process is 1 254.57 kgce(kilogram of standard coal equivalent)per ton of methanol,which is 4.46%lower than that of the pulverized coal gasification process(1 310.51 kgce).This is primarily attributed to the greater latent heat recovered in the shift unit of the coal-water slurry gasification process.As the oxygen/coal ratio increases,the energy consumption per ton of methanol for both processes first decreases and then increases.The optimal oxygen/coal ratio is 0.78 for coal-water slurry gasification and 0.66 for pulverized coal gasification,yielding minimum energy consumptions of 1 227.53 kgce and 1 242.43 kgce,respectively.Increasing the gasification pressure leads to a gradual reduction in energy consumption for both processes.Raising the pressure from 2.7 MPa to 8.7 MPa reduces energy consumption by 3.95%for coal-water slurry gasification(from 1 286.62 kgce to 1 235.77 kgce)and by 4.54%for pulverized coal gasification(from 1 359.89 kgce to 1 298.88 kgce).