宅基地资格权重获制度的法律构造与适用困境研究
Research on the Legal Structure and Application Dilemmas of the Homestead Qualification Right Reacquisition System
摘要
宅基地资格权作为"三权分置"改革中析出的新型权利,其退出后可否重获及依据何在等问题长期处于规范空白状态.由此,明确重获的规范依据与制度边界便成为当前宅基地制度改革亟待回应的命题.资格权的法律性质应定位为集体成员权的派生权利,重获则属于附条件的成员权再取得.同时,对各地方试点的类型化分析后表明,实践分化的规范根源在于权利性质理解不统一与权利变动规则缺失.为解决由此产生的权利构造不明、构成要件不清、利益调整机制缺位、权利实现路径不稳定四重困境,应将重获制度明确为保障性制度,从主体、实质、时间三者出发完成重获构成要件设计,建立以退出补偿为基础的补缴规则与多元履行方式,并通过程序法定与信息公开实现权利保障.
The homestead qualification right,as a new type of right derived from the"three-rights separation"reform,has long been subject to normative ambiguity regarding whether and on what basis it can be regained after withdrawal.Clarifying the normative foundation and institutional boundaries for regaining the qualification right is therefore a core issue in the current homestead system reform.The qualification right should be legally positioned as a derivative right of collective membership,and its reacquisition should be understood as conditional reacquisition of a membership right.A typological analysis of local pilots demonstrates that the normative root of practical divergence lies in inconsistent understandings of the right's nature and the absence of rules governing changes in rights.To overcome the fourfold dilemma—an unclear right structure,undefined legal requirements,a missing interest adjustment mechanism,and an unstable path for right realization—the reacquisition system should be clearly defined as a protective institution.Its design must address subjective,substantive,and temporal requirements,establish a repayment rule based on the original withdrawal compensation along with diversified methods of performance,and secure the realization of rights through procedural legalization and information disclosure.
年,卷(期):
2026, 42(3)
分类号:
D922.32
机标分类号:
D920.0
F301.3
F830.5
在线出版日期:
2026年7月21日
基金项目:
GD25CFX10:广东省哲学社会科学规划年度项目,