军事知识服务平台
欧盟防务合作的结构性困境与未来路径
Structural Dilemmas and Future Pathways of EU Defense Cooperation:A Mul-tidimensional Perspective on Permanent Structured Cooperation (PESCO)
摘要 在俄乌冲突重塑地缘格局与美国对欧战略承诺波动的双重冲击下,欧盟以"重新武装欧洲"计划为标志,加速从"规范性力量"向"地缘政治实体"转型.本文以《里斯本条约》框架下的"永久结构性合作"机制为切入点,通过项目布局解构与成员国行为分析揭示欧盟防务合作的深层矛盾与路径分野.研究发现,永久结构性合作框架下的83个项目虽形成陆海空天网多维能力矩阵,但成员国基于产业禀赋与地缘诉求的差异化参与,催生了"技术等级制"与"机会主义突围"并存的碎片化格局,共同塑造了欧盟防务合作中不对称的权力生态.实证研究表明,欧盟防务合作存在四大结构性困境:产业与地缘驱动的合作碎片化导致跨领域协同失效,法德核心矛盾与中小国家策略分化引发共识凝聚危机,集群化合作加剧"局部深化、整体割裂"悖论,北约标准依赖与欧盟技术主权诉求形成深层冲突.欧盟防务合作的未来路径呈现三重分野:高整合潜能路径依赖法德妥协与外部危机倒逼,通过超国家机构突破主权壁垒;均衡发展路径延续弹性多边主义,在有限领域推进标准兼容;碎片化崩溃路径则因法德对立、美国施压与经济衰退,滑向技术主权崩溃与地缘阵营分裂.
Abstract:
Under the dual impacts of the Russia-Ukraine conflict and the US' fluctuating strategic commitment to Europe,the EU is accelerating its transformation from a"normative power"to a"geopolitical actor",as exemplified by its ReArm Europe Plan.Starting from the Per-manent Structured Cooperation(PESCO)mechanism,this article analyzes its project dis-tributions and member state behaviors in order to discover the underlying contradictions and divergent trajectories of EU defense cooperation.The authors find that although PESCO pro-jects have established a multidimensional capability matrix spanning land,sea,air and space,differentiated participation driven by industrial endowments and geopolitical interests has created a fragmented landscape,which has in turn shaped an asymmetric power ecolo-gy.Empirical analysis reveals the following four structural dilemmas:fragmentation driven by industrial and geopolitical logics undermining cross-domain coordination;core Franco-German tensions and strategic divergences among small and medium states creating a con-sensus crisis;clustered cooperation exacerbating the paradox of"partial deepening versus overall disintegration";and reliance on NATO standards clashing fundamentally with the EU's pursuit of technological sovereignty.The future of EU defense cooperation may pro-gress along one of the three divergent paths:a highly-integrated trajectory contingent on Franco-German compromise and external crises,a balanced development path which ex-tends flexible multilateralism and advances standard compatibility in selective domains,or a fragmentation and collapse scenario with the erosion of technological sovereignty and divi-sion of geopolitical alignments.
刊 名 欧洲研究 PKU
年,卷(期): 2025, 43(4)
机标分类号: F270 D81 D992
在线出版日期: 2025年9月17日
基金项目: 22CSS018:国家社会科学基金24SKGH028:重庆市教育委员会人文社会科学青年项目,