Characteristics of highly cited papers in drainage and irrigation and pathways to increase their publication proportion:a case study of Journal of Drainage and Irrigation Machinery Engineering
摘要
为揭示灌排领域高被引论文的特征,并将文献计量分析结果转化为提升专业期刊高被引论文刊载比例的可执行策略,以《排灌机械工程学报》为目标期刊,将《灌溉排水学报》和《节水灌溉》作为同领域对标期刊,基于中国知网导出的高被引论文样本,采用描述统计、下载-引用耦合分析、主题归类、对应分析、集中度分析和熵权 TOPSIS 等方法开展定量和定性研究.结果表明,三刊高被引样本均体现较高的基金资助比例和团队合作特征;目标期刊样本总下载量为 97 845次、总引用量为 5 222 次,下载-引用相关系数为0.883,高于 2 种对标期刊,表明其阅读关注与学术复用之间具有较强同步性.主题结构上,目标期刊高被引论文主要集中于"排灌装备与泵阀过滤器",同时朝作物水肥、节水灌溉和智慧监测等方向延伸;对应分析表明,其差异化优势来自装备机理与工程应用的紧密联系,但主题集中度较高也限制了跨学科引用半径.熵权 TOPSIS 结果表明,目标期刊在本文指标体系下的贴近度为0.302 8,提示其应把装备优势嵌入国家水安全、数字灌区、节水农业和绿色低碳等更大范围中.灌排领域高被引论文的形成受需求牵引、方法复用、团队积累、知识组织和传播放大 5 类机制共同作用;《排灌机械工程学报》可通过装备与场景结合、高复用稿件挖掘、核心作者与青年梯队协同、基于四象限分析的刊后运营等路径,提高高被引论文刊载比例和期刊学术影响力.
To reveal the characteristics of highly cited papers in the field of irrigation and drainage,and to translate bibliometric findings into actionable strategies for increasing the share of highly cited papers published in specialized journals,quantitative and qualitative research was conducted by taking the Journal of Drainage and Irrigation Machinery Engineering(JDIME)as the target journal,as well as the Journal of Irrigation and Drainage(JID)and Water Saving Irrigation(WSI)as peer benchmark journals.Samples of highly cited papers exported from CNKI(China National Knowledge Infrastructure)were analyzed using methods such as descriptive statistics,download-citation coupling analysis,thematic classification,correspondence analysis,concentration analysis,and entropy-weighted TOPSIS to conduct quantitative and qualitative research.The results show that the highly cited samples from all three journals exhibit relatively high proportions of grant-funded articles and strong team-collaboration characteristics.The target journal′s sample has a total of 97 845 downloads and 5 222 citations,with a download-citation correlation coefficient of 0.883,which is higher than that of the two benchmark journals,indicating a strong synchronicity between readership interest and aca-demic reuse.In terms of thematic structure,highly cited papers in the target journal focus primarily on″irrigation and drainage equipment,pumps,valves,and filters″,while also extending into areas such as crop water and fertilizer management,water-saving irrigation,and intelligent monitoring.Correspon-dence analysis shows that its distinctive advantage stems from the close integration of equipment mecha-nisms with engineering applications.However,the relatively high thematic concentration also limits the scope of its cross-disciplinary citation reach.The entropy-weighted TOPSIS results show that the target journal has a closeness coefficient value of 0.302 8 under the established indicator system,suggesting that it should integrate its equipment-related advantages into broader contexts such as national water se-curity,digital irrigation districts,water-saving agriculture,and green low-carbon development.The emergence of highly cited papers in the field of irrigation and drainage is driven by the combined action of five mechanisms:demand-driven orientation,method reuse,team accumulation,knowledge organi-zation,and dissemination amplification.JDIME can improve the publication share of highly cited papers and enhance its academic influence by integrating equipment with application scenarios,culti-vating highly reusable manuscripts,fostering collaboration between core authors and young emerging research talents,as well as implementing post-publication operations based on four-quadrant analysis.