军事知识服务平台
碳排放数据质量责任的程序性展开
The Procedural Allocation of Responsibility for Carbon Emission Data Quality:Centering on the De-termination of Legal Facts under Article 1037 of the Ecological and Environmental Code of the Peo-ple's Republic of China
摘要 《中华人民共和国生态环境法典》第一千零三十七条并非对《碳排放权交易管理暂行条例》相关规定的简单法律位阶提升.对照法典初次审议稿与最终通过文本,"履行强制减排责任"的要求以及数据真实性、准确性和完整性责任均在立法审议过程中得到强化,碳排放数据由此从企业内部技术管理对象,转变为确定配额清缴义务的程序性事实基础.沿循"数据生成-核证-认定-责任追究"的履约链条,重点排放单位承担源头排放数据及年度排放报告的真实性、准确性和完整性责任,委托技术服务不产生责任转移之效果;受托技术审核机构承担行政法上的过程性专业勤勉义务,其是否尽责应结合专业能力配置、原始凭证核验情况、异常数据追问程度及核查底稿完整性等因素综合判断,不得仅以事后结果偏差为由直接推定其未尽义务;省级生态环境主管部门对实际排放量的确认,属于年度履约程序中的确认性行政决定,对清缴数额具有程序内基准效力,但该确认既不免除企业和核查机构在前端环节应承担的责任,也不免除主管部门独立履行审查职责之法定义务.法典施行后,《碳排放权交易管理暂行条例》仍需在数据质量控制、技术审核程序及责任后果等方面作出细化规定,其清缴罚则、资格限制措施及规范竞合规则均应与法典保持体系协调.源头记录保存、核查底稿编制、理由说明提供、异议复核机制、风险审查程序及行刑衔接安排,共同构成可追溯的事实认定程序框架,唯有如此,数据质量责任方能获得切实的制度落地保障.
Abstract:
Article 1037 of the Ecological and Environmental Code of the People's Republic of China does more than simply elevate the legal rank of the relevant provisions of the Interim Regulations on the Administra-tion of Carbon Emissions Trading.A comparison between the first deliberative draft and the final enacted text reveals that the requirement to"fulfill mandatory emissions reduction obligations",as well as the re-sponsibility for data authenticity,accuracy,and completeness,were both strengthened during the legislative deliberation process.As a result,carbon emission data have shifted from being merely internal technical management objects for enterprises to becoming the procedural factual basis for determining the obligation to surrender allowances.Along the compliance chain of"data generation-verification-determination-ac-countability",key emitting entities bear primary responsibility for the authenticity,accuracy,and complete-ness of source emission data and annual emission reports;entrusting technical services does not effect a transfer of such responsibility.Entrusted technical verification agencies assume a procedural duty of profes-sional diligence under administrative law.Whether they have fulfilled this duty should be assessed compre-hensively in light of factors such as the adequacy of professional expertise,the verification of original vouchers,the extent of inquiry into abnormal data,and the completeness of verification working papers.A breach of duty should not be inferred solely from discrepancies in the final results identified after the fact.The confirmation of actual emissions by the provincial competent ecological and environment department constitutes a confirmatory administrative decision within the annual compliance procedure,and has a benchmark effect on the amount of allowances to be surrendered within that procedure.However,such confirmation neither relieves enterprises or verification agencies of their upstream responsibilities,nor re-duces the statutory duty of the competent department to independently perform its review obligations.Af-ter the Code enters into force,the Interim Regulations on the Administration of Carbon Emissions Trad-ingwill still need to provide detailed rules on data quality control,technical verification procedures,and li-ability consequences;its provisions concerning penalties for failures to surrender allowances,restrictions on professional eligibility,and the resolution of overlaps among applicable legal norms must remain systemati-cally aligned with the Code.The retention of source records,preparation of verification working papers,reason-giving requirements,procedures for objections and review,risk-based review procedures,and co-ordination between administrative and criminal enforcement together constitute a traceable framework for factual determination.Only through such a framework can the responsibility for data quality be effectively secured by institutional implementation.
刊 名 鄱阳湖学刊
年,卷(期): 2026, (4)
机标分类号: D922.1 F205 TP309
在线出版日期: 2026年9月20日
基金项目: 2026JX026:中央高校基本科研业务费专项,