From Embeddedness to Disembeddedness:The Local Governance Logic of Resilience Decline and Reconstruction in Small-Scale Fisheries—Evidence from Coastal Communities in Four Provinces
摘要
小规模渔业深度嵌入沿海社区的社会结构、地方性知识体系与近岸生态系统,长期构成社会-生态系统耦合运行的典型实践.文章基于海南、广东、福建、浙江四省沿海社区的长期追踪调研,分析在资本集中化、技术标准化、治理体系层级化传导与生态退化多重压力叠合下,小规模渔业主导生计模式从系统嵌入走向结构性脱嵌的演变过程.研究发现,小规模渔业韧性衰减并非市场波动与资源衰退的自然结果,而是基层治理中的权责配置与资源管理方式在实践运作中的结构性后果:治理重心过度上移,弱化了社区自主治理与多元共管传统,使地方适应性管理失去制度支撑;标准化技术治理挤占地方经验知识的应用场域,造成本土知识合法性式微;资源权属界定模糊,收窄了渔民对近岸水域的使用与生产自主空间.三重机制叠加压缩渔民生计空间,损耗传统知识传承、社区社会网络与青年从业意愿,形成劳动力存量尚足但生产自主性萎缩的脱嵌型均衡.立足现有法律制度与行政管理体系,重建小规模渔业韧性需着力于拓宽地方主体治理参与渠道,推动本土知识与现代技术治理衔接,明晰近海渔业资源的使用权边界与社区共管规则,构建多元协同的包容性治理模式.
Small-scale fisheries are deeply embedded in the social structures,local knowledge systems,and nearshore ecosystems of coastal communities,and have long constituted a typical practice of social-ecologi-cal system coupling.Drawing on longitudinal fieldwork in coastal communities across Hainan,Guangdong,Fujian,and Zhejiang provinces,this study examines the evolution of small-scale-fishery-based livelihoods from systemic embeddedness to structural disembeddedness,under the combined pressures of capital con-centration,technological standardization,hierarchical transmission of governance,and ecological degrada-tion.The findings reveal that the decline in the resilience of small-scale fisheries is not a natural conse-quence of market fluctuations or resource depletion,but rather a structural outcome of how authority and responsibilities are allocated and resources are managed in local governance practice.Specifically,the exces-sive upward shift of governance authority undermines community self-governance and the tradition of multi-stakeholder co-management,thereby depriving local adaptive management of institutional support;standardized technical governance narrows the scope for the application of local experiential knowledge,accelerating the delegitimization of local knowledge;and unclear resource property rights practically con-strain fishers'access to nearshore waters and their autonomy in production arrangements.The cumulative effects of these three mechanisms constrain fishers'livelihood space,undermine the transmission of tradi-tional knowledge,community social networks,and young people's willingness to enter the fishery sector,and result in a disembedded equilibrium characterized by a still-adequate labor supply but declining pro-ductive autonomy.Within the existing legal and administrative framework,rebuilding the resilience of small-scale fisheries requires broadening channels for local stakeholders to participate in governance,pro-moting the integration of local knowledge with modern technical governance,clarifying the boundaries of rights to use nearshore fishery resources and the rules for community co-management,and building an in-clusive and collaborative governance model.