军事知识服务平台
风险预防原则在气候司法中的适用
The Application of the Precautionary Principle in Climate Adjudication
摘要 当前,风险预防原则在气候司法中的适用面临风险发生可能性认定模糊、预期后果严重程度要求不一以及关联对象差异性考量不足等问题,导致该原则或被虚置、或被滥用.为落实《生态环境法典》预防气候风险的要求,应构建以"合理可能性""损害严重性"及"法益特定性"为核心要素的复合适用标准."合理可能性"限定风险发生阈值,要求风险具备最低限度的现实可能性,达到基于IPCC概率分级体系中的"可能"(≥66%)及以上水平."损害严重性"限定损害后果阈值,对"严重性"的判断须以具有不可逆性与影响广泛性且超出社会可容忍限度为基准."法益特定性"作为调适标准,通过引入法益层级秩序与受体脆弱性考量,实现对原则适用的价值校准与情境化权衡.三项要素共同构成《生态环境法典》风险预防原则在气候司法中之适用标准.
Abstract:
Currently,the application of the precautionary principle in climate adjudication faces challenges such as ambiguity in determining the likelihood of risk occurrence,inconsistent requirements regarding the severity of an-ticipated consequences,and insufficient consideration of differences among affected parties.These issues lead to the principle being either rendered ineffective or abused.To implement the requirements for preventing climate risks set forth in the Ecological and Environmental Code,a composite application standard centered on the core elements of"reasonable likelihood","severity of harm"and"specificity of legal interests"should be established."Reasonable likelihood"defines the threshold for risk occurrence,requiring that the risk possess a minimum level of realistic pos-sibility,reaching the"likely"(≥66%)level or higher based on the IPCC probability classification system."Severity of harm"defines the threshold for harmful consequences;the assessment of"severity"must be based on the criteria of irreversibility,widespread impact,and exceeding socially tolerable limits."Specificity of the legal interest"ser-ving as an adaptive criterion,achieves value calibration and contextual balancing in the application of the principle by incorporating considerations of the hierarchical order of legal interests and the vulnerability of at-risk receptors.To-gether,these three elements constitute the application criteria for the precautionary prevention principle under the Ecological and Environmental Code in climate adjudication.
刊 名 齐鲁学刊 PKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (5)
分类号: D912.6
机标分类号: D922.68 TM721 TD-05
在线出版日期: 2026年11月6日
基金项目: :湖北省社会科学基金重点项目,