The Visualized Analysis of the Study of"Transnational Administrative Law Enforcement"(2002-2022)
摘要
"跨国行政执法"是对行政机构执法效果溢出本国内部秩序的学术描摹.其兴起主要源自经济全球化的演进、行政向国际的延伸、国际法理念的更迭、域外管辖的扩张.其研究意义在于解释并完善行政机构跨国执法的理论与实践,推动执法国兼顾国家利益与国际秩序,促进实体与个人的合规与救济.通过CiteSpace与VOSviewer软件对近20年国内外研究展开文献计量分析,有助于探测文献分布、知识群落、主题演变,进而分析理论发展趋势.基于知识图谱的可视化分析发现:该议题日趋以具体行为的合法性与合理性为焦点,以执法国的多重价值平衡为目标,因国际法的不完备性陷入执法评价困难,却为丰富管辖理论、执法理论、国别研究、专题研究提供契机,尤其在法律系统内部,该议题重点指向概念、原则、类型、程序、责任、救济的具体问题以及执法与立法、司法,国内法与国际法,执法国、执法目标及其母国的关系问题.在当前国际背景下,作为执法国与目标国,我国跨国行政执法同样亟待回应前述问题.
"Transnational Administrative Law Enforcement"is an academic description of the law enforcement effect of administrative agencies overflowing the internal order of the country.Its rise mainly stems from the evolution of economic globalization,the extension of administration to the world,the changes in the concept of international law,and the expansion of extraterritorial jurisdiction.Its research significance lies in explaining and perfecting the theory and practice of transnational administrative law enforcement,and stimulating law enforcement countries to take into account national interests and international order,promoting compliance and relief between entities and individuals.Through CiteSpace and VOS viewer software,the bibliometric analysis of related research scattered in various departments in the past two decades is carried out,aiming to detect the literature distribution,citation correlation,theme evolution,and then analyze the development trend of related theories.Visual analysis based on knowledge graph reveals that the topic is increasingly focusing on the legality and reasonableness of specific acts and aiming at the balance of multiple values of law-enforcement countries,and is caught in the predicament of law-enforcement evaluation due to the incomplete nature of international law,but it also provides opportunities for enriching theories of jurisdiction,law-enforcement theory,country studies,and thematic studies.Especially within the legal system,the topic focuses on the specific issues of concepts,principles,types,procedures,responsibilities,and remedies,the relationship between law enforcement and legislation,the judiciary,domestic law and international law,law enforcement countries,law enforcement targets and their home countries.In the current international context,as both a law-enforcement country and a target country,China's transnational administrative law enforcement also urgently needs to respond to the aforementioned issues.