军事知识服务平台
地方金融组织准入许可监管困境的现实逻辑与法治进路
Realistic Logic and Legal Approach to the Supervision Dilemma of Local Financial Organizations' Access Permission
摘要 基于控权逻辑的《行政许可法》第15条第2款导致实践中地方政府限制地方金融组织市场准入的做法面临合法性质疑.该困境的现实逻辑:一是实践层面,准入许可监管是应对地方金融监管权责失配的现实需求;二是法律层面,"自上而下"的刚性立法无法有效供给地方金融监管需求.解决困境的关键在于如何理解《行政许可法》第15条第2款中"应由国家统一确定"的表述.在新经济业态对《行政许可法》和地方政府监管提出挑战的背景下,有必要对"应由国家统一确定"进行限缩解释,扩大地方立法空间以满足监管需求.在此基础上,从立法层面采取"省级地方性法规先行、中央立法保有纠正权"的立法构造以及在"法律特区"试点行政备案制以弱化事前准入监管,并强化以信息披露为核心的事中事后监管的双重进路是解决地方金融组织市场准入监管困境的可行之策.
Abstract:
Article 15,paragraph 2,of the Administrative License Law based on the logic of power control leads to the legitimacy disputes of local government's practice of restricting the market access of local financial organizations.The realistic logic of this dilemma lies in the following:first,the supervision of access permission at the realistic level is to meet the realistic demand arising from a mismatch between regulatory authority and responsibility in local financial supervision;second,the rigid legislation of"top-down"at the legal level can't effectively supply the demand of local financial supervision.The key to solve the dilemma lies in how to understand the expression"should be determined by the state"in Article 15,paragraph 2 of the Administrative Licensing Law.Under the background that the new economic format challenges the Administrative Licensing Law and local government supervision,it is necessary to make a restrictive interpretation of"should be determined by the state"and expand the local legislative space to meet the regulatory needs.From the legislative level,adopting the legislative structure of"provincial local regulations first,and the central legislation retains the right to rectification"and piloting the administrative filing system in"special legal zones"to weaken the prior access supervision and strengthen the dual approach of post-event supervision with information disclosure as the core is a feasible strategy to solve the market access dilemma of local financial organizations.
年,卷(期): 2023, (2)
机标分类号: D922.11 F830.3 D631.4
在线出版日期: 2026年9月21日
基金项目: 2017BFX015:上海市哲学社会科学一般课题,