军事知识服务平台
超越私权:作为社会资源的数据要素及其治理
Beyond private rights:data elements as social resources and its governance
摘要 《个人信息保护法》中的公私法比例与导向处于失衡的状态,在以私权创设和救济规则为主要组成的"私权化"治理路径下,数据要素被完全界定为一种个人资源,引发了数据主体与处理者之间的失衡权力结构.以"信息受托人"为代表的"私权化"改良方案存在不恰之处,根本原因是数据要素极为有限的个人资源属性.将数据要素界定为个人资源的做法忽略了数据要素在社会群体层面的利益.数据要素的基本定位是一种社会资源,具有维护国家数据主权、保障社会安全与提升社会福祉三重面向.迈向公私合作的数据治理需要厘清公私法的边界,完善公法规制机构设置与行政措施.公法还需深度介入并调整现有私权创设与救济规则.
Abstract:
The"Personal Information Protection Law"is currently in a state of imbalance regarding the proportion and orientation of public and private law.Under the predominant"privatization"governance path,which focuses on the establishment and remedial rules of private rights,data elements are solely defined as personal resources.This has led to an imbalanced power structure between data subjects and data processors.The"privatization"reform proposal,represented by the concept of"information trustee",has its inadequacies,primarily because the personal resource attribute of data elements is extremely limited.Defining data elements as personal resources overlooks the broader societal interests associated with data elements at the social group level.The fundamental positioning of data elements should be as a social resource,serving three dimensions:safeguarding national data sovereignty,ensuring social security,and enhancing social welfare.Moving towards a collaborative governance approach between public and private sectors requires clarifying the boundaries between public and private law,improving the establishment of public law regulatory institutions and administrative measures.Public law also needs to be deeply involved and adjust existing private rights establishment and remedial rules.
年,卷(期): 2023, (2)
机标分类号: I206 D923.4 F294
在线出版日期: 2026年9月21日
基金项目: 25QD33:对外经济贸易大学中央高校基本科研业务费专项,