军事知识服务平台
国际供应链中商事合同人权保证条款
Human Rights Assurance in Commercial Contracts within the Global Supply Chain—A Doctrinal Study Grounded in German and EU Law
摘要 "国际供应链"概念的提出,使非跨国公司参与国际贸易活动时的人权责任成为国外学界最近的研究焦点,也是域外立法的最新发展.德国《供应链法》、欧盟《企业可持续性尽责指令(提案)》创设了强制的人权保证合同机制,标志着在公法之外,私法成为规制企业人权尽责的新途径.在私法中讨论企业的人权责任,德国立法未选择侵权法,而是采用合同法,可能的原因之一是扩大企业人权侵权民事责任在教义学上面临挑战,是故侵权法的预防功能交由合同法来发挥.然而,与一般合同条款不同,人权保证条款由立法强制要求订立,并入的内容也可能是我国并非缔约国的条约或外国公法的规定.这为在合同法框架下分析此种新类型合同条款带来了新挑战、新问题.在国际商事合同准据法为德国法的前提下,"人权战略"和"行为准则"是格式条款,能否纳入取决于格式条款审查.纳入后,还需判断是否存在"利用优势经济地位"致使违背善良风俗的情形.对第三方劳动者而言,人权保证条款不构成对第三人具有保护效力的合同,但可能构成利于第三人的合同.对第三方公司而言,"二级保证"较难通过格式条款审查,即使能够纳入,也可能因"限制经济选择自由"或为第三人设立负担而归于无效.
Abstract:
The introduction of the concept of"international supply chain"has made human rights responsibilities for non-multinational companies participating in international trade the recent focus of foreign academia and the latest development in foreign legislation.The German Supply Chain Law and the EU Directive on Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence(Proposal)establish mandatory contractual mechanisms for human rights assurance,signaling a shift in the regulation of corporate human rights responsibilities from public law to private law.In this context,German laws have opted for contract law over tort law,partly due to doctrinal challenges in expanding civil liability for corporate human rights violations.As a result,the preventive function of tort law has been delegated to contract law.However,unlike typical contract clauses,human rights assurance clauses are legislatively mandated and may include provisions from unratified treaties or foreign public law.This presents new challenges and issues for analyzing such new types of contract clauses within the framework of contract law.Under the premise of German law as the governing law for international commercial contracts,"human rights strategy"and"code of conduct"are essentially that of standard terms,and their inclusion depends on the scrutiny.After inclusion,it is necessary to determine whether there is an"exploitation of superior power"leading to a violation of common decency.For third-party laborers,human rights assurance clauses do not constitute contracts with protective effects on third parties but may be contracts beneficial to third parties.For third-party companies,the inclusion of"secondary assurance"is difficult to pass through standard terms scrutiny,and even if included,it may be void for"restricting economic choice freedom"or imposing burdens on third parties.
年,卷(期): 2023, (2)
机标分类号: D923.6 F276.7 F741
在线出版日期: 2026年9月21日
基金项目: :国家建设高水平大学公派研究生项目,