摘要
加强对行政法基本原则的研究,对助力行政法法典化具有基础性意义.明确性原则最初滥觞于刑法罪刑法定主义,随后逐渐从大陆法系刑法领域外溢到所有公法领域,成为具有宪法位阶的公法原则.明确性原则在大陆法系的德国已经被确立为行政法基本原则,英美法系中也存在类似的概念.但明确性原则在中国行政法学界讨论较少,尚未取得基本原则的地位.丰富的备案审查和裁判文书案例说明,明确性原则不仅可以适用于具体行政行为,还可以适用于抽象行政行为、双方行政行为和行政事实行为,是一项适用于所有类型行政行为的法律原则,理应被确立为行政法上的基本原则.法的安定性原则和法律明确性原则是行政法上明确性原则的法理基础.明确性原则的基本含义,是指行政行为的内容应当明确,构成要件和法律效果皆应明确,即行政行为为相对人设定的权利义务应当明确.行政行为欲符合明确性原则,需要满足可理解性、可预见性、可审查性三项要素的判断标准.不符合明确性原则的行政行为的效力应当界定为可撤销.明确性原则属于实质法治而非形式法治范畴,不能被行政合法性原则、行政合理性原则涵括,而是应当与之平行并列为行政法的一项基本原则.
Strengthening the research on the basic principles of administrative law is of fundamental significance to promoting the codification of administrative law.The principle of definiteness originated from the doctrine of legally prescribed crime and punishment in criminal law,and then gradually overflowed from the criminal law field of civil law system to all public law fields,becoming a public law principle with constitutional rank.The principle of clarity has established the basic principles of administrative law in Germany and Taiwan,but not in the Chinese mainland.The rich cases of record review and judgment documents show that the principle of clarity can be applied not only to specific administrative acts,but also to abstract administrative acts,administrative acts of both parties and administrative factual acts.It is a legal principle applicable to all types of administrative acts,and should be established as the basic principle of administrative law.The principle of legal stability and the principle of legal clarity are the legal basis of the principle of clarity in administrative law.The basic meaning of the principle of clarity means that the content of the administrative act should be clear,and the constituent elements and legal effects should be clear,that is,the rights and obligations set by the administrative act for the opposite party should be clear.In order to comply with the principle of clarity,administrative acts need to meet the judgment criteria of three elements:comprehensibility,predictability and justiciability.When an administrative act does not conform to the principle of clarity,the effectiveness should be defined as revocable.The principle of clarity belongs to the category of substantive rule of law rather than formal rule of law.It can not be included by the principle of administrative legitimacy and the principle of administrative rationality,but should be parallel to it and listed as the basic principle of administrative law.