The Shift of"Principle Permission"Legislative Model for Share Repurchase under the Authorized Capital System
摘要
股份回购有两种立法模式:一种是"原则禁止,例外允许"模式,另一种是"原则允许,例外禁止"模式.我国公司法仍然坚持采取"原则禁止,例外允许"的立法模式.2023年《中华人民共和国公司法》对股份公司实行授权资本制.股份回购的立法模式也应发生转向."原则禁止,例外允许"立法模式的目的是为克服股份回购所可能引发的问题.但在授权资本制下,股份回购的诸多弊端可以有效抑制,同时也能够实现公司持有自己股份的理论自洽.有必要从股份回购的正面价值出发,逐渐采取更加宽松、缓和的立法态度,实现股份回购制度"原则允许"模式的立法转向.采取"原则允许"的立法模式后,相关的制度需要进一步调整.包括重新建构新的规范体系,以尽可能发挥股份回购的功能,减轻股份回购的弊端,提升系统的协调性和规范效率.
There are two legislative models for share repurchase:one is the"principle prohibition with exceptions"model,and the other is the"principle permission with exceptions"model.China's Company Law still adheres to the"principle prohibition with exceptions"legislative model.The Company Law of the People's of China(Revised in 2023)implements the authorized capital system for joint-stock companies.The legislative model for share repurchase should also shift.The purpose of the"principle prohibition with exceptions"legislative model is to overcome the possible problems caused by share repurchase.Under the authorized capital system,many drawbacks of share repurchase can be effectively curbed,and the theoretical consistency of a company holding its own shares can also be achieved.It is necessary to gradually adopt a more lenient and moderate legislative attitude starting from the positive value of share repurchase,and move towards the legislative direction of the"principle permission"model.After adopting the"principle permission"legislative model,relevant systems need to be further adjusted.This includes reconstructing a new normative system to maximize the functions of share repurchase,mitigate its drawbacks,and enhance the coordination and efficiency of the system.