军事知识服务平台
平行诉讼风险下"适当联系"管辖的解释运用
Interpreting"Appropriate Connection"Jurisdiction Through the Lens of Parallel Litigation Risk
摘要 2023年修订的《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》第276条第2款确立"其他适当联系"条款,将涉外管辖的连结方法由封闭列举转向开放补充.与第1款列举连结点相比,第2款的开放性不仅拓宽了管辖入口,也制造了特殊的"策略性不确定性":当事人可以利用"适当性"标准的裁量空间在多个法域同步布局,以管辖异议本身为程序筹码,在涉单边制裁纠纷等高对抗性场景中显著推高平行诉讼概率.这一风险结构决定了第276条第2款的解释运用不能停留在"何种联系够格"的静态阈值判断,而须将"行使管辖是否会触发或加剧平行诉讼对抗"纳入动态评估.以涉单边制裁纠纷为主要观察场景,但所提解释框架普遍适用于一般涉外管辖.在区分"管辖权成立"与"管辖权行使"的基础上:管辖权成立层面,平行诉讼风险要求将正面阈值从"联系存在"提升至"联系能够支撑有效的诉讼集中化",以"实质联系—可预见性—裁判有效性"三重标准予以校验;管辖权行使层面,通过尊重排他性协议、中止诉讼与不方便法院等程序阀门将裁量导向"控制竞争"而非"争夺管辖",使第276条第2款与第280~282条形成"入口约束—协调出口"的体系衔接,在救济可得性与国际可辩护性之间实现可操作的平衡.
Abstract:
Paragraph 2 of Article 276 of the 2023 Civil Procedure Law introduces an"other appropriate connection"clause,transforming the methodology for foreign-related jurisdiction from closed enumeration to open-ended supplementation.Unlike the enumerated connecting factors in paragraph 1,this open-ended provision not only expands access to Chinese courts but also introduces a distinctive"strategic uncertainty":parties may exploit the discretionary latitude inherent in the"appropriateness"standard to forum-shop across multiple jurisdictions simultaneously,deploying jurisdictional objections as procedural leverage.In highly adversarial contexts-notably disputes involving unilateral sanctions-this dynamic significantly increases the risk of parallel litigation.This risk structure demands that the interpretation of Article 276(2)move beyond the static threshold question of whether a connection is sufficient,and incorporate a dynamic assessment of whether exercising jurisdiction would trigger or exacerbate parallel litigation conflicts.This article distinguishes between the establishment of jurisdiction and its exercise.At the level of jurisdictional establishment,the risk of parallel litigation requires raising the threshold from the mere existence of a connection to whether that connection is capable of supporting effective litigation consolidation,tested against a tripartite standard of substantive nexus,predictability,and enforceability of judgment.At the level of jurisdictional exercise,procedural mechanisms such as respect for exclusive jurisdiction agreements,stays of proceedings,and forum non conveniens should channel judicial discretion toward managing jurisdictional competition rather than fueling it.This creates a systematic linkage between Article 276(2)and Articles 280-282,forming a"controlled entry-coordinated exit"architecture that strikes a workable balance between access to remedies and international defensibility.
刊 名 时代法学
年,卷(期): 2026, 24(3)
分类号: D997.3
机标分类号: D925.1 F832.2 TU981
在线出版日期: 2026年11月4日
基金项目: 20250184:八桂学者团队项目,