On the Legal Norms and Administrative Coordination Balance of Village Regulations and Folk Norms in the Construction of Civilized Rural Customs
摘要
村规民约作为重要的乡村自治规范,如何发挥其在文明乡风建设中的规范功能、实现制度适配,是推进乡村振兴战略的必要环节.村规民约在运行中同时存在法治规范与行政协调失衡的问题:在法治规范层面,存在制定程序违法、内容与国家法冲突、实施救济机制缺位等规范漏洞;在行政协调层面,呈现行政干预过度、跨区域协调失灵、权责边界模糊等制度缺陷;二者进一步衍生出价值冲突、权限冲突、程序冲突三重矛盾.从法学视角提出系统性平衡路径:通过构建"合法性审查—程序规制—监督问责"的法治化运行体系,夯实村规民约的规范基础;通过确立"权责清单—协同机制—程序公开"的行政协调框架,界定行政介入的合法边界;最终依托立法确权、救济衔接、价值融合,搭建法治规范与行政协调的平衡机制,为破解"行政替代自治""法律悬浮于习俗"难题提供理论方案,助力乡风文明建设向"自治、法治、德治"融合转型.
As an important norm for rural self-governance,how to leverage the regulatory function of village regulations and folk customs in the construction of civilized rural customs and achieve institutional adaptation is a necessary step in promoting the rural revitalization strategy.In the operation of village regulations and folk customs,there exists an imbalance between legal norms and administrative coordination.In terms of legal norms,there exist normative loopholes such as illegal formulation procedures,content conflicts with national law,and the lack of an implementation and relief mechanism.Regarding administrative coordination,institutional flaws are evident,including excessive administrative intervention,ineffective cross-regional coordination,and ambiguous power and responsibility boundaries.These issues further give rise to three sets of contradictions:value conflicts,power conflicts,and procedural conflicts.From a legal perspective,this paper proposes a systematic approach to achieving balance.By establishing a legal operating system encompassing"legitimacy review-procedural regulation-supervision and accountability",the normative foundation of village regulations and conventions can be strengthened.Through the establishment of an administrative coordination framework consisting of a"power and responsibility inventory-coordination mechanism-procedural transparency",the legitimate boundaries of administrative intervention can be clearly defined.Ultimately,by relying on legislative rights confirmation,relief connection,and value integration,a balanced mechanism between legal norms and administrative coordination can be established.This not only offers a theoretical solution to the challenges of"administrative substitution of self-governance"and"the detachment of law from local customs",but also facilitates the transformation of rural customs construction towards the integration of"self-governance,the rule of law,and virtue governance".