军事知识服务平台
功能主义视角下民营企业内部背信犯罪立法修正的理解与适用
The Understanding and Application of the Legislative Amendment of the Crime of Breach of Trust in Private Enterprises from the Perspective of Functionalism
摘要 《刑法修正案(十二)》对背信犯罪的修改使得刑事制裁范围得以拓展至民营企业,但实践中仍存在诸多问题亟待解决.在刑法扩张与限缩适用的两难抉择中,功能主义刑法观提供了一种全新的思维范式与解释进路,强调在解释过程中吸纳刑事政策等因素,实现合理性与合目的性的统一.在此指引下,我国背信犯罪的保护法益是企业的财产权和信任关系,应站在"实质职权说"的立场对不同主体规定作同等理解.在实行行为方面,"违反法律、行政法规规定"是真正的、不成文的构成要件要素,"利用职务之便"的认定必须融合形式判断与实质判断.犯罪结果的计算标准宜与国企保持一致,同时充分尊重企业自治,重视组织决议阻却刑事违法性的法律效果.贯彻宽严相济的刑事政策,注重解释结论的法律效果与社会效果,才能真正落实平等保护民营企业的政策要求.
Abstract:
The Amendment(Ⅻ)to Criminal Law to the crime of breach of trust has expanded the scope of criminal sanctions to private enterprises,but there are still many problems to be solved in practice.In the dilemma between expanding and limiting the application of criminal law,the functionalist view of criminal law provides a new thinking paradigm and interpretation approach,emphasize the incorporation of factors such as criminal policy in the interpretation process,so as to realize the unity of rationality and purposiveness.Under this guidance,the protected interest of the crime of breach of trust in our country is the property right of the enterprise and trust relationship,and we should stand on the"substantive authority theory"to understand the provisions of different subjects equally.In the aspect of implementing behavior,"violating the provisions of laws and administrative regulations"is the real and unwritten constituent element,and the identification of"taking advantage of one's position"must combine formal and substantial judgments.The calculation standard of crime results should be consistent with that of state-owned enterprises,while fully respecting the autonomy of enterprises and paying attention to the legal effect of organizational resolutions to prevent criminal illegality.Only by implementing the criminal policy of tempering justice with mercy and paying attention to the legal and social effects of the explaining conclusions can we truly implement the policy requirements of equal protection of private enterprises.
刊 名 时代法学
年,卷(期): 2026, 24(3)
分类号: D924.33
机标分类号: D925.2 F270.7 G649.1
在线出版日期: 2026年11月4日
基金项目: 202510813:中南财经政法大学中央高校基本科研业务费专项,