论类案适用冲突的方法论化解
On the Resolution of Conflicts in the Application of Similar Cases
摘要
适用类案裁判是统一法律适用的重要方式,但目前却存在类案适用冲突的化解难题.对此,可在方法论层面构建递进式的化解程式.首先应进行待决案件事实的认定和规范目的的获取,随后在系列类案中发现承载规范目的之描述性意义的事实特征,最后在规范目的指引下开展待决案件和类案的事实比对,从而通过确立相关类案来化解类案适用冲突.如果待决案件中的证据事实含有多个指向不同规范目的的事实特征,则需开展规范目的之间的权衡论证.在进行目的权衡时,应在明确它的权衡对象、制度限制和主体要求的基础上,通过不利的潜在性后果之间的比较来确定哪一规范目的在待决案件情境中最为重要,并运用合法性、融贯性和可接受性标准检验目的权衡的结果,进而确保含有胜出规范目的的类案与待决案件是相关相似的.
Applying similar case in the judgement of pending case is an important way of harmonizing the application of the law,but at present there are difficulties in resolving conflicts in the application of similar cases.In this regard,a progressive resolution program can be constructed at the methodological level.First of all should be the determination of the facts of the pending case and the acquisition of normative purposes,and then find descriptive factual characteristic pointing to normative purposes in a series of similar cases,and finally compare facts of the pending case and the class of cases under the guidance of normative purposes,so as to establish the relevant similar case to resolve the conflict of application of similar cases.If the evidentiary facts in the pending case contain multiple factual features pointing to different normative purposes,it is necessary to carry out a weighing argument between the normative purposes.When weighing purposes,based on a clear understanding of the object of the weighing,the institutional limitations and the subjective requirements of the weighing,the comparison of potential adverse consequences should be used to determine which normative purpose is the most important in the context of the pending case,and the criteria of legitimacy,coherence and acceptability should be applied to test the results of the weighing of purposes,thus ensuring that the similar case containing the winning normative purpose is relevant and similar to the case at hand.
年,卷(期):
2026, 24(3)
分类号:
D915.1
机标分类号:
D925.2
B81
G124
在线出版日期:
2026年11月4日
基金项目:
2025QBE003:陕西省社会科学基金青博项目,