军事知识服务平台
破产法上程序型和解的要素化转向
The Shift from Procedural-Type Composition to an Elemental Approach in Bankruptcy Law
摘要 自破产和解程序作为独立程序引入破产法伊始,其制度价值便饱受争议.完善论和废止论的争议聚焦于具体制度的检视,未能从法理和体系视角展开系统性反思.程序型和解的存续不具有坚实的法理基础,其法理悖论集中表现为和解文化与程序构造的非唯一性、多元程序设计与制度功能的非适配性以及预防式立法理念与消极导向的非契合性.其结果是,程序型和解在内部体系上无法调和"自由"与"强制"之间的价值冲突,以致其未能建构逻辑自恰的外部体系.值此破产法修改之际,破产法上的和解应由程序型和解转向要素型和解,放弃独立破产和解程序的立法模式,转而以要素的方式融入重整程序.要素型和解建构的具体路径应从两个维度展开:在宏观维度,应注重理念更新和结构转变;在微观维度,应注重制度的协商转向,包括但不限于债务人自行管理制度、债权人会议制度以及和解协议(条款)的司法审查标准等具体制度的改造.
Abstract:
Since the introduction of the bankruptcy composition proceeding as an independent procedure into bankruptcy law,its institutional value has been a subject of ongoing controversy.The debate between proponents of its retention and advocates of its abolition has largely centered on the examination of specific rules,without engaging in a systematic reflection from the perspectives of legal theory and systemic coherence.The continued existence of procedural-type composition lacks a solid jurisprudential foundation.Its theoretical paradoxes are primarily manifested in three aspects:the non-uniqueness of settlement culture and procedural structure,the misalignment between diversified procedural designs and institutional functions,and the incongruity between preventive legislative philosophy and its inherently passive orientation.Consequently,at the level of internal systematization,procedural-type composition fails to reconcile the value conflict between"freedom"and"coercion,"thereby preventing the construction of a logically coherent external system.Against the backdrop of the current revision of the Bankruptcy Law,it is proposed that bankruptcy composition shift from a procedural modelto an elemental model-that is,abandoning the legislative framework of an independent bankruptcy composition proceeding and instead integrating composition elements into the reorganization process.The concrete pathways for constructing such an elemental model should be developed along two dimensions:at the macro level,emphasis should be placed on conceptual renewal and structural transformation;at the micro level,the focus should be on reorienting the system toward negotiation-based mechanisms,including but not limited to reforms to the debtor-in-possession management system,the creditors' meeting mechanism,and the judicial review standards applicable to composition agreements(or clauses).
刊 名 时代法学
年,卷(期): 2026, 24(3)
分类号: D922 D291 D92
机标分类号: D616 G410 D922.291.92
在线出版日期: 2026年11月4日