Process-oriented Governance:What Makes Points-based Management Effective in Township Governance?
摘要
政策落实是乡镇治理的核心任务.随着基层治理现代化的推进,既往依托权力支配、利益关系、组织动员推动政策落实的路径,因约束性手段与激励性资源不足而难以奏效,需要突破以目标管理与责任管理为核心的分析框架,通过过程介入与柔性引导破解政策落实这一困境.在实践中,积分制管理将政策落实过程分解为可识别、可记录、可评价的具体行动单元,通过任务分解、指标管理与考核激励,实现治理压力的有序传导、治理责任的有效落实以及治理动力的持续激发.由此,原本模糊、弹性的政策执行状态被转化为清晰、可视的治理过程,乡镇政府对政策执行的可见性、可控性与可问责性得以增强.过程化治理视角弥补了基层政策落实研究在过程维度上的不足,也为理解技术治理如何重塑乡镇政府与村组织的关系、推进基层治理现代化提供了新的分析思路.
Policy implementation is the core task of township governance.With the advancement of grassroots governance modernization,previous approaches to policy implementation that relied on power-based domination,interest-based relations,and organizational mobilization have become ineffective due to insufficient restrictive means and incentive resources.It is necessary to move beyond the analytical framework centered on target management and responsibility management and to resolve this dilemma of policy implementation through process intervention and flexible guidance.In practice,points-based management decomposes the policy implementation process into identifiable,recordable,and assessable specific action units.Through task decomposition,indicator management,and assessment-based incentives,it achieves the orderly transmission of governance pressure,the effective fulfillment of governance responsibilities,and the sustained stimulation of governance motivation.As a result,the originally vague and flexible state of policy implementation is transformed into a clear and visible governance process,and the township government's visibility,controllability,and accountability over policy implementation are enhanced.The process-oriented governance perspective remedies the deficiency of grassroots policy implementation research in the process dimension and provides a new analytical approach for understanding how technical governance reshapes the relationship between township governments and village organizations and advances the modernization of grassroots governance.