"1525年革命":19世纪以来德国农民战争的史学建构
'The Revolution of 1525':The Historiographical Construction of the German Peasants' War since the 19th Century
摘要
德国农民战争爆发以来五百年间,人们对其认识和评价经历了从消极到积极的态度转变.在长达三个世纪里,它曾被视为一场破坏性叛乱,或者仅仅是为了经济利益而进行的斗争.直到1848年革命前夕,它才引起学界关注,被界定为一场革命,并由此代表了德国历史上的某种关键性转折.不同政治背景的史学家对"1525年革命"的内涵给予了不同诠释,这种诠释与德国的政治历史变迁紧密相连.恩格斯将其界定为"第一号资产阶级革命"的组成部分,并认为其中产生了共产主义萌芽;20世纪中叶前后,出现了西方学者的"民族的政治革命说"与马克思主义阵营的"早期资产阶级革命"命题的分歧;到20世纪70年代,布利克勒整合东西方学者观点,从近代国家构建视角提出"普通人的革命"命题.梳理"1525年革命"的史学建构历程,可为研究德国近代化特殊道路及欧洲近代早期政治转型提供参考.
Over five centuries since the outbreak of the German Peasants' War in 1525,interpretations of this movement have undergone an attitude shift from predominantly negative judgments to more affirmative reassessments.In three centuries,it was marginalised either as a destructive rebellion or a struggle mere for economic interests.It was not until the eve of the 1848 Revolution that the movement attracted substantial scholarly attention and came to be interpreted as a revolution,representing a pivotal turning point in the German history.Historians from diverse ideological backgrounds have endowed the meaning of'The Revolution of 1525'with varying interpretations,which had close connections with transformations of the German political history.Friedrich Engels defined it as an integral component of the'first Bourgeois Revolution'and discerned the embryonic seeds of communism within it.Around the mid-20th century,a divergence emerged between the theory of'national political revolution'by the Western scholars and the proposition of'early bourgeois revolution'in the Marxist camp.By the 1970s,Peter Blickle integrated perspectives of scholars from both the East and the West,proposing the landmark thesis of the'Revolution of the Common Man'from the analytical perspective of early modern state-building.The historiographical construction of'The Revolution of 1525'provides an important reference for re-examining Germany's Sonderweg of modernisation and the political transformation of early modern Europe.
年,卷(期):
2026, (4)
机标分类号:
G219.19
D64
K561.4
在线出版日期:
2026年9月15日