Nature,Culture and History:Historical Thoughts and Characteristics of Carl O.Sauer's Historical Geographic Research
摘要
美国历史地理学奠基人卡尔·索尔对于美洲历史地理的研究,具有以下三个方面的贡献:一是基于文化区发展互动的研究方法,突破了既往研究对于美洲文化群体的均质认识,尤其强调对边缘地区、过渡地带的研究.二是环境反应理论下的本土与多元文化视角,注重地方知识或本土观念的合理性,反思和批判资本主义所谓的"普世"思想.三是生态视野下的历史地理研究,关注人类及其文化对于自然景观的影响与改造,将人与自然视为协同发展的共同体,并对殖民主义、资本主义文明观、科技滥用等进行批判.文化、生态、环境、景观及其互动关系是索尔历史地理学研究的主要着眼点,多元性、本土性、动态性、反思性则是其研究的重要特征.索尔的史学理论是正值转型期的美国历史学、地理学发展的产物,反过来又助推历史学、地理学等学科的转型,为美国历史地理学的发展奠定了基础,并在相当程度上为20世纪六七十年代美国环境史的兴起提供了理论借鉴.
Carl O.Sauer,the founder of the American historical geography,made contributions to the historical geographic research of the Americas in three major aspects.First,he adopted a research approach centred on the developmental interactions of cultural regions,breaking the previous homogeneous perception of the American cultural groups and particularly attaching the research of marginal areas and transitional zones.Second,from an indigenous and multicultural perspective grounded in the environmental response theory,he affirmed the rationality of local knowledge and indigenous ideologies,while reflecting on and criticising the so-called'universalist'ideology of capitalism.Third,he conducted historical geographic research from an ecological perspective,focusing on human societies and their cultural reshaping and transformation of natural landscape.Moreover,he regarded humans and nature as a community of coordinated development and launched critiques against colonialism,capitalist civilisational values,and the abuse of science and technology.The core focus of Sauer's historical geographic research lied in culture,ecology,environment,landscapes and their interactive relationships,while pluralism,indigeneity,dynamism and critical reflexivity constituted the salient features of his scholarship.Sauer's historiographical theories emerged amid the disciplinary transformation of the American history and geography,and in turn promoted the paradigm shift of those disciplines.Accordingly,he laid the foundational framework for the American historical geography and provided substantial theoretical reference for the rise of the American environmental history studies in the 1960s and 1970s.