军事知识服务平台
从"政治反帝"到"全面反帝":近代英国反帝思想中的两种取向
From'Political Anti-Imperialism'to'Comprehensive Anti-Imperialism':Two Orientations of Anti-Imperialist Thought in Modern Britain
摘要 自19世纪中叶至第一次世界大战期间,英国的反帝思想作为对资本主义扩张的批评者逐渐发展起来,并对20世纪初期的马克思主义和国际主义都产生了重要影响."政治反帝"和"全面反帝"两种取向构成了近代英国反帝思想的政治光谱,前者反对侵略战争和武力扩张,将帝国主义根源归结为英国封建贵族的好战和掠夺天性,同时鼓吹英国主导的"自由贸易"体系;后者以霍布森对帝国主义的系统性分析作为起始点,在反对侵略战争的同时,将资产阶级的逐利动机作为帝国主义的经济根源加以批判,并在文化上开始反思欧洲中心论和白人至上论.在霍布森之后,伍尔夫、比尔、海德门等英国反帝主义者又丰富和推进了这一路径.然而,英国反帝思想整体上具有明显的局限性,幻想在不触动资本主义体制的前提下构建超民族国家组织和建立委任统治制度,因而不可能构建一种真正超越帝国主义的国际新秩序.
Abstract:
From the mid-19th century to the period of the First World War,the thought of anti-imperialism in Britain gradually developed as a critique of imperialist expansion and exerted a significant influence on both Marxism and internationalism in the early 20th century.Two orientations of'political anti-imperialism'and'comprehensive anti-imperialism'constituted two extremes of the political spectrum of modern British anti-imperialism.The former opposed wars of aggression and military expansion,attributing the roots of imperialism to the bellicose and predatory nature of the British feudal aristocracy,while advocating for a British-led'free trade'system.The latter took J.A.Hobson's systematic analysis of imperialism as its starting point.While opposing wars of aggression,it criticised the bourgeoisie's profit-seeking motives as the economic roots of imperialism and began to question the ideologies of Eurocentrism and White Supremacy.Following Hobson,the British anti-imperialists such as Leonard Woolf,Max Beer,and H.M.Hyndman further enriched and advanced that approach.However,the British anti-imperialism as a whole had clear limitations.It harbored the illusion that,without challenging the capitalist system,the establishment of supranational organisations and the mandate system could provide a solution.As a result,it was impossible for the British anti-imperialism to construct a new international order that'truly transcended imperialism'.
刊 名 世界历史 PKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (4)
机标分类号: D815 K252 D047
在线出版日期: 2026年9月15日
基金项目: 1919-1949)(21CZS050:国家社会科学基金,