From Tribal Conflict to Monarchical Autocracy:A Study of Tribal Factors in the Second Fitna of the Umayyad Caliphate
摘要
伍麦叶王朝时期(661-750年)爆发的第二次菲特奈是早期国家从部落到部落联盟,再到专制主义帝国动态演进的缩影.菲特奈参战各方由部落力量构成,成败由部落立场决定,表明菲特奈的本质为部落战争.在较量中伍麦叶家族遵循部落社会运行机制,深谙嵌套式权力体系,秉持"阿萨比亚"行为准则,顺应部落逐利性,拉拢南方部落势力;更有北方部落为支持伍麦叶家族通过拟制血缘变更谱系.伍麦叶家族最终获胜,平息菲特奈.此后,为削弱部落离心倾向,伍麦叶哈里发阿卜杜·马利克着手削弱部落贵族,加强集权,改革币制,建立常备军,进而缔造了王朝中兴.第二次菲特奈是伍麦叶王朝整合松散部落社会结构的契机,加速了部落社会向阿拉伯封建帝国的过渡.但多元部落通过谱系重组演变为南北两大政治集团,在战后积极参与哈里发继承人斗争,为伍麦叶王朝灭亡埋下隐患.
The Second Fitna,which broke out during the Umayyad period(661-750),epitomised the dynamic transformation of the early polity from a fragmented tribal society through tribal confederations into an autocratic empire.All parties involving in the Fitna drew their forces from the tribes,and the outcome of the conflict hinged on tribal allegiances,indicating that the Fitna was essentially a war among tribes.In the struggle,the Umayyads abode by the operation mechanism of tribal society.They skillfully navigated the nested structure of authority,upheld'asabiyya'as a guiding principle of conduct,accommodated the tribes' pursuit of material interests,and courted the support of the southern tribes.Some northern tribes even reconfigured their genealogical affiliations through fictive kinship in order to support the Umayyads.The Umayyads ultimately prevailed and brought the Second Fitna to an end.Thereafter,aiming at curbing the separatist tendencies of the tribes,Abd al-Malik,the Umayyad caliph,set about weakening the tribal aristocracy,centralising the political authority,reforming the coinage,and establishing a standing army,which ushered in a revival of the dynasty.The Second Fitna provided the Umayyad Caliphate with an opportunity to consolidate its loosely structured tribal society and accelerated the transition of that society into an Arab feudal empire.Nevertheless,through genealogical reconfiguration,various tribes coalesced into two major political blocs of the North and the South.Their active participation in postwar struggle over the Umayyad succession sowed the seeds of the eventual downfall of the dynasty.