军事知识服务平台
地区研究的史前史:19世纪篇
The Prehistory of Area Studies:The Nineteenth Century
摘要 本文考察19世纪美国多种域外知识因素和部门及其演进与制度脉络,以期推进地区研究史的历史纵深.文章首先分析相关学术史,指出美国地区研究(Area Studies)的概念化和历史撰述长期受"冷战社会科学"范式支配,与其相适配的"'二战'起源说"导致对战前历史源流的忽视.笔者主张以"域外研究"和"总体史"等扩张性知识史观念拓展对地区研究的概念化和叙事议程,并运用多种知识史分类和"分型"工具对美国域外研究予以识别、收纳和历史化处理.本文依次探讨如下问题:古典学、语文学和东方学构成19世纪专深人文学知识的"母体学科",为域外知识提供语言训练、文献考证与方法论基础;新教海外传教运动孕育"传教士东方学"与"智识国际主义",以在地语言沉浸、文献整理、类社会科学因素与跨国网络,构成后世地区研究的"田野工作认识论"与文化相对主义的早期源流;19世纪晚期人文学领域(域外考古、艺术史、现代语言学、历史学、比较宗教学等)在学科专业化进程中达成域外知识的显著增殖,初步形成海外研究据点、人文学范围内的跨学科格局,并对美国世界历史文明观念产生直接和潜在影响.本文强调,19世纪美国域外知识主要植根于人文学博通传统,具有丰富多样性、历史连续性与鲜明美国特性,为20世纪中叶地区研究的制度化与"全世界覆盖"格局提供了不可或缺的知识库存、学术文化积累,奠定了制度与人员基础.本文的全部讨论指向"史前史"作为著史范畴所具有的巨大的分析意义和广阔的实证研究空间.
Abstract:
This article examines various elements,departments,evolutionary paths,and institutional contexts of foreign area knowledge in the nineteenth-century United States,aiming to expand the historical depth of the history of Area Studies.Beginning with an analysis of the relevant historiography,the article points out that the conceptualization and historical narratives of American Area Studies have long been dominated by the paradigm of"Cold War Social Science",and its companion narrative,the"World War Ⅱ origin theory",has led to a neglect of pre-war historical origins and lineages.The author advocates for expanding the conceptualization and narrative agenda of Area Studies through expansive concepts in the history of knowledge,such as"foreign area studies"and"total history",and for utilizing various tools of classification and typology in the history of knowledge to identify,incorporate,and historicize American foreign area studies.The paper sequentially explores the following dimensions:First,classics,philology,and Oriental studies constituted the"parent disciplines"of advanced humanistic learning in the nineteenth century,providing language training,textual criticism,and methodological foundations for foreign area knowledge.Second,the Protestant overseas missionary movement nurtured"missionary Orientalism"and"intellectual internationalism";through in-situ linguistic immersion,documentary organization,quasi-social-scientific elements,and transnational networks,it formed the early genealogy of the"fieldwork epistemology"and cultural relativism of later Area Studies.Third,during the process of disciplinary professionalization in the late nineteenth century,various humanistic fields(such as foreign archaeology,art history,modern linguistics,history,and comparative religion)achieved a significant proliferation of foreign area knowledge,initially established overseas research outposts and an interdisciplinary framework for the area-focused knowledge within the humanities,and exerted direct and potential influences on American conceptions of world history and civilization.This article emphasizes that nineteenth-century American foreign area knowledge was primarily rooted in the scholarly tradition of the humanities,possessing rich diversity,historical continuity,and distinct American characteristics.It laid an indispensable knowledge repository,academic-cultural accumulation,and institutional and personnel foundation for the institutionalization and"complete world coverage"pattern of Area Studies in the mid-twentieth century.The entire discussion in this article points toward the immense analytical significance and vast space for empirical research inherent in"prehistory"as a historiographical category.
年,卷(期): 2026, 13(3)
机标分类号: G254.1 B920 H030
在线出版日期: 2026年8月18日
基金项目: 21BSS017:国家社会科学基金,