Cost efficiency analysis of Hyphantria cunea management in Jining city,Shandong province,China
摘要
美国白蛾Hyphantria cunea是我国重点管控的外来入侵物种,对我国森林资源和绿化景观构成严重威胁.为解决当前美国白蛾防治工作中缺乏多种防治方法组合评估经济效益的问题,以山东省济宁市为例,对比综合防治、无人机化学防治和物理生物防治方法的防治效果,参考物资资源损失、关联产业损失和防治费用损失的三维评估模型,评估美国白蛾危害损失,分析不同防治方法的成本效益.结果表明:综合防治组和无人机化学防治组对美国白蛾幼虫的防治效果显著优于物理生物防治组;2023年济宁市美国白蛾直接经济损失3 915.76万元,其中物资资源损失占比最高,为49.04%,防治费用占比为34.92%,关联产业损失占比为16.04%;无人机化学防治的成本为12.75元/hm2,效益最高,为2 687.25元/hm2,可服务于大面积防控;综合防治与物理生物防治成本效益相近,但综合防治兼具速效性与可持续性优势.研究结果为林草有害生物防治管理机构制定精准防控策略提供决策依据.
Hyphantria cunea,a key invasive alien species under strict control in China,has caused extensive damage to forest resources and urban landscapes.To address the current lack of economic benefit assessment for combinations of multiple control methods in the management of H.cunea,a case analysis in Jining city,Shandong province was conducted.Through comparative assessments of integrated control,drone‑based chemical control,and physical and biological control methods,the control efficacy was validated.Employing a three‑dimensional evaluation model that encompasses loss of material resources,related industrial,and control costs,the economic damage caused by H.cunea infestations was quantified.The results demonstrated that both the integrated control group and chemical control group exhibited significantly superior efficacy against H.cunea larvae compared to the physical and biological control group.In 2023,the direct economic losses caused by H.cunea infestations in Jining city reached 39.16 million CNY,with material resource losses accounting for the highest proportion of 49.04%,followed by control cost losses of 34.92%and related industries losses of 16.04%.Drone‑based chemical control,with the lowest implementation cost of 12.75 CNY/hm2,achieved the highest cost efficiency of 2 687.25 CNY/hm2 and could serve large‑scale prevention and control.Although integrated control and physical and biological control showed comparable cost efficiency,the former demonstrated advantages in both rapid response and sustainability.The study results provides quantitative decision‑making support for precision pest management strategies in forestry administration.