军事知识服务平台
不同自然分布地刺五加资源药用品质的综合评价
Comprehensive Evaluation of Medicinal Quality of Eleutherococcus senticosus Resources from Different Natural Distribution Areas
摘要 以刺五加苷B(eleutheroside B)等5种单体活性成分和总糖等3类活性物质总量,以及药典规定的总灰分和甲醇浸出物质量分数等10个指标,通过单指标评价与层次分析-熵权法评价相结合的方法,对黑龙江、吉林、辽宁、河北和山西5个刺五加(Eleutherococcus senticosus)自然分布地的野生刺五加资源进行综合评价.结果显示,27个刺五加样品在各评价指标上都表现出了较大的变化,其中,异嗪皮啶在黑龙江2份样品间质量分数相差700倍以上,刺五加苷B质量分数在吉林和黑龙江的2份样品间相差16倍以上,而综合评价的分值在黑龙江和河北2份样品间相差也接近6倍.各省平均水平显示,河北样品绝大部分指标都低于其他4省,其中甲醇浸出物、刺五加苷B、刺五加苷E、绿原酸质量分数等重要指标都比黑龙江低40%以上.山西样品虽然在甲醇浸出物、绿原酸、总糖质量分数以及综合评价得分上占有优势,但是总灰分和刺五加苷B的质量分数却不符合药典规定.层次分析-熵权法评价中,黑龙江和山西样品在综合评价得分上为较优水平,其中黑龙江样品的评价得分比吉林样品高14%以上.进一步对刺五加各评价指标与环境因子进行相关分析,结果发现年均温度、年均降水量和年日照时数分别与总灰分、总皂苷和异嗪皮啶质量分数存在显著正相关(P<0.05).因此,综合考虑单项指标、药典标准以及综合评价得分情况,黑龙江为优质刺五加原料产地和种源地,这与此地区具有较低温度和较高降水量等生长条件有关.
Abstract:
Using 10 indicators including five monomer active ingredients such as eleutheroside B,three types of active substances such as total saccharides and two indicators specified in the pharmacopoeia such as total ash and methanol-soluble extract content,a comprehensive evaluation was conducted on wild Eleutherococcus senticosus resources from Hei-longjiang,Jilin,Liaoning,Hebei,and Shanxi provinces,through a combination of single-indicator evaluation and ana-lytic hierarchy process-entropy weight method evaluation.The results showed that there were significant variations in all evaluation indicators among the 27 samples.The maximum difference in the content of isofraxidin between two samples from Heilongjiang was over 700 times,a difference of 16 times in the content of eleutheroside B between two sample from Jilin and Heilongjiang and a difference fo nearly 6 times in the comprehensive evaluation score between the two sample from Heilongjiang and Hebei.From the average level of each province,samples from Hebei were lower than those from other provinces in most indicators,with important indicators such as methanol-soluble extract,eleutheroside B,eleu-theroside E,and chlorogenic acid content being more than 40%lower than those from Heilongjiang.Although samples from Shanxi had advantages in methanol-soluble extract,chlorogenic acid,total saccharides content and comprehensive evaluation score,but the total ash and eleutheroside B content did not meet the pharmacopoeia requirements.In the com-prehensive evaluation using the analytic hierarchy process-entropy weight method,samples from Heilongjiang and Shanxi exhibited superior scores.Notably,the sample from Heilongjiang scored over 14%higher than the sample from Jilin.The further correlation analysis between evaluation indicators and environmental factors revealed significant positive correla -tions(P<0.05)between annual average temperature,annual average precipitation,and annual sunshine hours with total ash,total saponin,and isofraxidin content,respectively.Therefore,considering individual indicators,pharmacopoeial standards,and comprehensive evaluation scores,Heilongjiang is a high-quality production and provenance area for Eleu-therococcus senticosus,which is related to its growth conditions of lower temperature and higher precipitation.
刊 名 森林工程 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 42(5)
分类号: S789.9
机标分类号: F326.13 R284.1 S567
在线出版日期: 2026年9月17日
基金项目: 2019FY100506:国家基础科技资源调查专项,