Research on Public Library Law of the People's Republic of China from the Perspective of Legal Interests:Morphological Structure,Generation Logic and Optimization Path
摘要
采用主题内容分析法,以法益为交切点,提炼归纳《公共图书馆法》法益结构基本特征后发现,从回应型到社会友好型立法理念的转变是推动《公共图书馆法》嵌入相对均衡的"社会法益—国家法益—个人法益"一体三元法益束结构的直接动因,领域法的共同属性是造就《公共图书馆法》国家法益、社会法益和个人法益在形态分布上相对汇聚的技术缘因,为公众服务的现代公共图书馆精神的植入是《公共图书馆法》释放出以个人社会化法益为主导的本位法益变迁信号的实质内因.新时期,我国应当以国家法益、社会法益和个人法益的动态均衡为核心导向,以社会法益的有效实施为基础指引,以个人法益的合理保护为中心面向,持续注入以用户为中心和为公众服务的基本理念,整体完善《公共图书馆法》一体多元的法益结构,构建兼具"软法之长"和"硬法之优"的混治实施模式.未来公共图书馆事业发展应从以下3个方面完善:在《公共图书馆法》中增加个人法益类型条款,科学配比社会法益、国家法益和个人法益;以强化个人法益类型条款执行效力为视角,践行以用户为中心的立法理念,加大对侵犯个人法益行为的惩戒强度;面向用户推进《公共图书馆法》的宣传普及工作.
By adopting the thematic content analysis method and taking legal interests as the intersection point,this study refines and summarizes the basic characteristics of the legal interest structure of Public Library Law of the People's Republic of China.It is found that the transformation of legislative concept from a responsive type to a socially friendly type is the direct driving force for promoting Public Library Law of the People's Republic of China to be embedded in a relatively balanced integrated tripartite legal interest bundle structure of"social legal interests-national legal interests-individual legal interests".The common attributes of domain law are the technical reason for the relatively converged morphological distribution of national legal interests,social legal interests and individual legal interests in Public Library Law of the People's Republic of China.The integration of the modern public library spirit of serving the public is the substantive internal reason why Public Library Law of the People's Republic of China releases the signal of the change of standard legal interests led by individual socialized legal interests.In the new era,China should take the dynamic balance of national legal interests,social legal interests and individual legal interests as the core orientation,take the effective implementation of social legal interests as the basic guidance,and take the reasonable protection of individual legal interests as the central focus.It is necessary to continuously inject the basic concepts of user-centeredness and serving the public,comprehensively improve the integrated and diversified legal interest structure of Public Library Law of the People's Republic of China,and construct a mixed governance implementation model that combines"the advantages of soft law"and"the merits of hard law".The future development of public library services should be improved in the following three aspects:add provisions on the types of individual legal interests to Public Library Law of the People's Republic of China,and scientifically balance social legal interests,national legal interests,and individual legal interests;from the perspective of strengthening the enforcement effect of the provisions on the types of individual legal interests,practice the user-centered legislative concept and increase the intensity of punishment for acts that infringe on individual legal interests;promote the publicity and popularization of Public Library Law of the People's Republic of China among users.