军事知识服务平台
政策工具供给促进公共文化服务发展的组态路径
Configurational Paths of Policy Tool Supply for Promoting Public Cultural Service Development
摘要 剖析政策工具选择实践,探究政策工具供给的有效路径,是创新公共文化服务发展的现实需求.文章选取我国2006-2024年间31个省份914份公共文化服务政策文本,采用内容分析法量化公共文化服务政策工具选择的特征,并以模糊集定性比较分析法总结政策工具供给促进公共文化服务发展的组态路径.研究发现,省级公共文化服务政策工具供给呈现内容共有、类型分化、结构失衡、互补替代的特征;公共文化服务发展水平的提升有赖于命令型、激励型、能力型、劝说型和变革型政策工具协同组配效应的发挥,政策工具供给组配的差异化效果促成命令规制型、多元激励型、能力补强型、治理协同型四条组态路径;加速公共文化服务体系的现代化转型与升级并非必然有赖于政策工具的数量叠加或比例配置,而是要以不同政策工具功能特性、地区资源禀赋与发展需求等为核心决策依据,强化政策工具组合与运用方式的适用性、匹配性、情境性,针对政策效力短板设计精准的适配路径.
Abstract:
Analyzing policy tool selection practices and exploring the effective pathways of policy tool supply are a practical necessity for innovation in public cultural service development.Through content analysis,this study quantifies the characteristics of policy tool selection in 914 public cultural service policies issued by China's 31 provincial-level administrative units from 2006 to 2024,and then applies fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis(fsQCA)to identify the configurational paths through which policy tool supply promotes the development of public cultural services.The study reveals that the supply of policy tools at the provincial level exhibits the characteristics of shared content,differentiated types,structural imbalance,and complementarity and substitutability.The advancement of public cultural services depends on the synergistic configuration effects of mandatory-type,incentive-type,capacity-building-type,persuasive-type,and transformative-type policy tools.The differentiated effects of policy tool configurations give rise to four configurational paths:mandatory-regulation,diversified-incentive,capacity-reinforcement,and governance-coordination.Accelerating the modern transformation and upgrading of the public cultural service system does not necessarily rely on the quantitative accumulation or proportional allocation of policy tools.Rather,decision-making should be grounded primarily in the functional characteristics of policy tools,regional resource endowments,and developmental needs,with emphasis on enhancing the applicability,compatibility,and contextual relevance of policy-tool combinations and their application methods,so as to design precise and adaptive paths that address shortcomings in policy effectiveness.
刊 名 图书馆论坛 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 46(11)
机标分类号: G252 F205 F4
在线出版日期: 2026年11月11日
基金项目: 23ZDAJ007:湖南省社会科学基金重大项目,