军事知识服务平台
AI时代数字人文平台版权治理的困境与路径
Digital Humanities Platforms at the Crossroads:Copyright Governance Dilemmas and Strategies in the Era of Generative AI
摘要 生成式人工智能的迅猛发展对现行版权法律体系构成结构性冲击.数字人文平台兼具"文化资源数字化聚合者、文本与数据挖掘(TDM)与AI训练的数据基础设施提供者、AI增强研究工具的集成者"三重角色,处于人文学术研究与版权保护冲突的核心交汇点.厘清其版权治理困境并提出应对路径,对保障学术研究自由、维护文化遗产开放获取具有重要意义.文章运用比较法与案例分析法,系统梳理中美欧三大法域的立法、司法判例及政策文本,基于"输入端—过程端—输出端"治理链条深入剖析数字人文平台面临的三重困境:输入端存在公有领域文化遗产数字化作品的版权状态不明与出版商许可协议的"契约式否决"、过程端存在TDM行为法律边界模糊与中间成果权属真空的保护困境、输出端面临生成内容的版权风险与平台责任升级风险;并从法律政策倡导、制度构建与国际协作三个层面提出应对路径,主张数字人文平台须从被动的版权合规执行者转型为主动的数字人文知识产权规则塑造者,在AI时代知识产权新秩序中确立自身不可替代的治理角色.
Abstract:
The rapid development of generative artificial intelligence poses structural challenges to the current copyright legal system.Digital humanities(DH)platforms simultaneously serve as aggregators of digitized cultural resources,data infrastructure providers for text and data mining(TDM)and AI training,and integrators of AI-enhanced research tools.This triple role places them at the critical intersection where humanities research and copyright protection converge.Clarifying the challenges they face in copyright governance and proposing solutions is of great significance for safeguarding academic freedom and ensuring open access to cultural heritage.Through comparative analysis and case study,this paper examines legislation,judicial precedents,and policy documents across three major jurisdictions—China,the United States,and the European Union.Using an"input–process–output"analytical framework,it systematically analyzes the threefold dilemma confronting DH platforms:at the input end,the unclear copyright status of digitized public domain cultural heritage works and the"contractual veto"imposed by publisher licensing agreements;at the process end,the blurred legal boundaries of TDM and the ownership vacuum regarding intermediate outputs;and at the output end,the copyright risks associated with generated content and the escalating risks of platform liability.The paper proposes a three-pronged approach—legal and policy advocacy,institutional development,and international collaboration—arguing that DH platforms must shift from passive enforcers of copyright compliance to proactive builders of DH intellectual property rules.In doing so,they can secure an irreplaceable governance role within the emerging intellectual property order of the AI era.
刊 名 图书馆论坛 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 46(11)
机标分类号: G40.52 G641 F327
在线出版日期: 2026年11月11日
基金项目: 24&ZD180:国家社会科学基金,