Crisis and Renewal of Film Auteur Theory in the Context of AI-Generated Moving Images
摘要
电影作者论从极端的导演作者论逐步转向温和的集体作者论,其理论前提是传统电影的集体生产结构.人工智能影像改变了这一前提,重新提出作者性的识别与归属问题.本文借助一组丹托式不可分辨性案例,比较视听表象完全相同的传统电影与人工智能影像:在前者中,视听表象沉积着多个主体的创作判断,从而指向集体作者论;在后者中,生成所得的视听表象不再作为可直接追溯的人类制作劳动的有机沉积物进入作者性结构,并经由观众的审美判断力而被剥离,从而使极端的导演作者论由一种不符合传统电影事实的设想转化为现实.因此,人工智能影像带来的并非电影作者论的消解,而是再生.然而,作为代价,它也使一种不完整的、超视觉的"观念电影"成为可能,并为观影经验带来一种新的贫乏化危机.由此,人工智能时代的电影创作与批评呼唤一种差异化判断:在承认人工智能影像使作者观念获得"直接影像化"的同时,重新确认传统电影"集体—感性"生成机制的不可替代性.
Film auteur theory gradually shifted from extreme director-centered auteurism toward a moderate theory of collective authorship,a development premised on the collaborative production structure of traditional cine-ma.AI-generated moving images alter this premise and reopen the question of how cinematic authorship should be identified and attributed.Drawing on Danto-inspired cases of indiscernibility,this article compares a conventionally produced film with an AI-generated film that is audiovisually indiscernible from it.In the former,the audiovisual surface embodies the creative judgments of multiple agents and therefore supports a theory of collective authorship.In the latter,the audiovisual surface constitutes a generated outcome rather than an organic deposit of directly trace-able human creative labor.The viewer's aesthetic judgment consequently detaches specific audiovisual features from their conventional attribution to identifiable human creators.Extreme director-centered auteurism is thereby transformed from a theoretical conception incompatible with the realities of traditional filmmaking into an actual pos-sibility.What AI-generated moving images bring about,therefore,is the renewal rather than the dissolution of film auteur theory.Yet this renewal comes at a price:it also makes possible an incomplete,supra-visual form of"con-ceptual cinema"and introduces a new crisis of impoverishment into the experience of film viewing.Film creation and criticism in the age of artificial intelligence consequently require a differentiated mode of judgment:while acknowl-edging that AI-generated moving images enable the direct audiovisual realization of authorial conception,we must reaffirm the irreplaceability of traditional cinema's collective-sensuous mode of production.