Doctrinal Justification and Institutional Construction of Procuratorial Public Interest Litigation Against Unfair Competition
摘要
数字经济的深度发展催生了新型不正当竞争行为,其系统性、隐蔽性与扩散性特征造成了传统行政监管的治理不畅与私益诉讼的救济梗阻,反不正当竞争检察公益诉讼作为公益保护的补位机制价值凸显.当前,该制度仍面临法定办案领域定位不明、立案标准缺失、公益损害后果认定困难、调查取证权的行使受限,以及既有办案规则与数字场景不适配等困境.未来须确立法定领域的独立定位,构建"行政公益诉讼为主、民事公益诉讼为辅"的双轨模式,从程序配置规范化、裁判规则精细化、协同机制系统化三个维度推进制度构建.在具体机制设置方面,应明确受案范围与立案标准,建立分级专属管辖,探索开展预防性检察公益诉讼;审慎适用惩罚性赔偿,规范电子数据证据规则,构建公益损害评估与量化标准;健全司法与行政监管的衔接联动机制,提升检察系统内部融合履职的效能,建立跨部门、跨区域联动机制,以及完善公众参与机制.
The in-depth development of the digital economy has given rise to new types of unfair competition acts,whose characteristics of systematicity,concealment,and diffusion have highlighted the governance shortcomings of traditional administrative supervision and the remedial bottlenecks in private-interest litigation.Against this backdrop,procuratorial public interest litigation against unfair competition has emerged as a pivotal supplementary mechanism for public interest protection.At present,procuratorial public interest litigation against unfair competition is confronted with practical dilemmas such as an ambiguous statutory positioning regarding the scope of case-handling authority,the absence of filing standards,difficulties in identifying the consequences of public interest harms,constraints on the exercise of investigation and evidence-collection powers,and incompatibility of existing case-handling rules with digital scenarios.In view of this,it is imperative to establish an independent statutory positioning for this domain and construct a dual-track model featuring"administrative public interest litigation as the principal avenue and civil public interest litigation as the supplementary avenue",and promote the institutional construction from three dimensions:standardization of procedural configuration,refinement of judgment rules,and systematization of collaborative mechanisms.In terms of specific mechanism design,efforts should be made to clarify the scope of accepted cases and filing standards,establish hierarchical and exclusive jurisdiction,explore preventive procuratorial public interest litigation,prudently apply punitive damages,standardize electronic data evidence rules,construct evaluation and quantification standards for public interest damage,and improve the implementation guarantee mechanisms for collaborative governance.