The Construction Path of Procedures for Handling Case-Related Property in the Context of the Fourth Revision of the Criminal Procedure Law
摘要
自1979 年《刑事诉讼法》施行以来,三次修法均对涉案财物处置有所关涉,但未能完成相应程序的系统建构,尚不能适应当前涉案财物数量多、数额大、权属复杂的实际.现行法律规范呈现出规定碎片化、法际协同不畅、功能发挥不足等现实缺憾.对此,应当借《刑事诉讼法》第四次修改的契机,着力推进涉案财物处置程序的系统建构.鉴于本次修法规模的实际情况,相关程序建构宜采取"立法完善+配套规范"的进路.在此进路之下,无论是立法层面的制度创设,还是配套规范的制度细化,都应当从涉案财物处置程序相对独立、惩罚犯罪与保障人权相统一、多元主体利益全面有效保护、程序公正与诉讼经济相平衡等四个方面进行价值考量.就具体操作层面而言,应当聚焦对物强制措施、先行处置、审理程序、利害关系人权利、相对分离对物之诉等重大问题,推进制度创新和配套规范细化,进而搭建起涉案财物处置程序的基本框架,推动形成对人之诉与对物之诉并重的刑事诉讼二元格局.
Since the enactment of the Criminal Procedure Law in 1979,its three prior revisions have addressed the handling of case-related property but failed to establish a systematic procedural framework.The current regime remains ill-adapted to the evolving reality characterized by a surge in the volume and value of such property,as well as increasingly complex ownership structures.Existing provisions suffer from fragmentation,insufficient inter-legal coordination,and limited functional efficacy.Leveraging the upcoming fourth revision of the criminal procedure law,it is imperative to systematically construct specialized procedures for handling case-related property.Given the anticipated scope of this revision,the construction should adopt a dual-track strategy of"legislative improvement+supporting norms".Under this framework,both legislative innovations and normative refinements must adhere to four core values:the relative independence of property-handling procedures,the unity of crime control and human rights protection,the comprehensive protection of multi-stakeholder interests,and the balance between procedural justice and litigation efficiency.Operationally,institutional reforms should focus on critical areas—including in rem compulsory measures,advance disposal mechanisms,adjudication procedures,the rights of interested parties,and relatively separated in rem litigation.This will lay the groundwork for a dualistic structure of criminal litigation that accords equal weight to in personam(against the person)and in rem(against the property)proceedings.