军事知识服务平台
论民事补充责任诉讼形态的识别
Identification of Litigation Forms in Civil Supplementary Liability
摘要 诉讼形态是处理特定纠纷的"最优解".当前理论上试图以某一诉讼形态统摄各类补充责任的规则适用,然而该方案与现行程序规范不相契合,所得诉讼形态亦不妥当,补充责任诉讼形态难以据此得以有效识别.究其原因,当前方案过于倚重诉讼标的的识别功能,普遍忽视了责任顺位的实现方式,亦未充分阐明责任范围认定对判断诉讼形态的影响.对此,诉讼形态的识别基准需要重新厘定,大陆法系"合一确定"应当作为判断的基础,其中先诉抗辩权具有程序与实体的双重属性,其行使效果排斥了"共同诉讼的必要",而"相应的"补充责任的责任范围应与主责任共同确定,形成"合一确定的必要".鉴于此,安全保障补充责任应适用单向(固有)必要共同诉讼,一般保证责任适用普通共同诉讼,而瑕疵股东责任可依附公司责任径直执行.通过实体类型与诉讼形态的适配,补充责任的程序规则得以在更深层次阐明.
Abstract:
Litigation forms serve as the"optimal solution"for resolving specific disputes.Current academic research attempts to subsume the procedural application of all categories of supplementary liability under a single litigation form.However,this approach is incompatible with existing procedural norms,and the litigation form derived therefrom is doctrinally untenable,rendering it impossible to effectively identify the proper litigation form for supplementary liability on this basis.The underlying reason is that the prevailing approach attaches excessive weight to the delimiting function of the object of action,generally overlooks the procedural mechanism for giving effect to the order of liability,and fails to fully expound the impact of liability scope determination on the identification of litigation forms.To address these issues,it is necessary to redefine the criteria for identifying litigation forms.The civil law system's concept of"unity of determination"should be taken as the basis for judgment.Moreover,the beneficium ordinis possesses dual procedural and substantive attributes,the exercise of which precludes the"necessity of joint litigation".Meanwhile,the scope of"corresponding supplementary liability"should be determined jointly with the primary liability,establishing a"necessity for unity of determination".Accordingly,the safety protection supplementary liability should be"jointly determined"with the direct liability,applying the unidirectional necessary joint litigation.The general guaranteed liability shall apply ordinary joint litigation.The defective shareholdersliability may not only be brought under the framework of necessary joint action,but also be enforced alongside directly coprorate liability.Through the alignment between substantive liability categories and procedural litigation forms,the rules governing supplementary liability can be elucidated at a more profound level.
刊 名 现代法学 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 48(4)
分类号: DF72
机标分类号: D925.1 P539.2 F270
在线出版日期: 2026年9月8日
基金项目: XJJSKYQD202504:中央高校基本科研业务费专项2025M770654:中国博士后科学基金面上资助项目,