摘要
行为人的行为与构成要件结果之间具有因果性是刑事归责的前提.因果流程在时间上都是向后发展的,任何情形下行为均无法回溯性地引起先前的违法事实.在中途参与的场合,不仅先行为人引起的违法结果不能由后行为人承继,而且先行为人的违法行为引起的被害人反抗被压制、心理畏惧或者认识错误的状态(效果)亦不能被承继,因此,承继共犯否定说具有妥当性.对承继共犯的否定并不意味着连事中的共同犯罪现象都要否定.依据因果共犯论与罪责自负原则,后行为人仅需对其参与后与先行为人共同实施的违法事实负责,并据此进一步判断二者是否成立事中的共同犯罪,以及后行为人应予承担的刑责范围.特别是,当违法结果究竟是发生于后行为人参与之前还是参与之后存在疑问时,不应将该结果归责于后行为人.共同犯罪的本质是"数人共犯数罪",而非"数人共犯一罪",当后行为人与先行为人构成共同犯罪时,二者所触犯的罪名未必相同(罪名独立性说).对于后行为人,应依据其在共同犯罪中所起的作用,相应地认定为主犯抑或从犯.
The existence of causality between the actions of the actors and the results of the constituent elements is a prerequisite for criminal liability.Moreover,all causal processes develop forward in time,and the conduct of the actor cannot retrospectively cause prior unlawful facts under any circumstances.In cases of subsequent participation,unlawful consequences caused by prior actors cannot be inherited by subsequent participants.Similarly,a subsequent participant cannot be held liable for the earlier conduct that had already placed the victim in a state(effect)of suppressed resistance,fear,or misperception.Accordingly,the theory denying successive complicity is sound.Denying successive complicity does not mean negating the phenomenon of joint offenses formed during the course of the crime.According to the theory of causal complicity and personal culpability,a subsequent participant is only responsible for the unlawful conduct jointly committed after joining the offense.This provides the basis for further determining whether a joint offense has been established between the parties and for delineating the scope of the subsequent participant's criminal liability.Especially in situations where doubt persists as to whether the unlawful result occurred before or after the subsequent participant's involvement,the responsibility should not be attributed to the later participant who joined in midway.Joint offenses should be understood as"multiple persons jointly committing multiple offenses",rather than"multiple persons jointly committing a single offense".Therefore,when a subsequent participant and a prior actor are deemed co-perpetrators,they may be charged with different offenses—a view known as the theory of independence of charges.Furthermore,the subsequent participant should be classified as a principal or an accessory based on the role played in the joint offense.