军事知识服务平台
行刑正当防卫的层级构造差异与衔接关系协调
Hierarchical Structural Differences Between Justifiable Defense in Administrative Penalty Law and Criminal Law and Coordination of Their Doctrinal Alignment
摘要 2025年修订的《治安管理处罚法》新增正当防卫条款,行刑正当防卫由此进入具体适用的新阶段.然而,理论与实务中普遍存在"同一论"观点,即主张行刑正当防卫的判断标准应完全一致.该观点已导致司法实践中出现规范适用的矛盾,并使两类正当防卫条款陷入双重"虚置化"的困境.基于不同部门法在规范目的、违法构成、责任后果等层级构造上的差异,应对行刑正当防卫的判断标准进行合理区分.总体上,应采取"行严刑宽"的区分原则,即在起因、时间、主观及限度等具体条件上,治安正当防卫的成立门槛应当高于刑法正当防卫.此种区分并非对法秩序统一的背离,恰恰是实现精细化、科学化、体系化行刑衔接的前提与核心手段.在厘定区分标准之后,可类型化构建"治安上构成防卫过当,刑法上构成正当防卫"等协调适用模式,这既能激活刑法正当防卫条款的出罪功能,又能实现对治安防卫行为的合理规制,最终达致法秩序内在的和谐统一.
Abstract:
The newly added provisions on justifiable defense under the 2025 revision of China's Public Security Administration Punishments Law have ushered in a new stage of application for justifiable defense across both administrative and criminal law domains.However,the widely held"theory of uniformity"in both academic discourse and judicial practice—which proposes that the criteria for determining justifiable defense in administrative and criminal contexts should be absolutely identical—has given rise to confusions in the application of legal norms and has rendered both sets of justifiable defense provisions doubly"nominalized".In view of the differences between administrative law and criminal law in terms of their hierarchical structures—including divergent legislative purposes,constituent elements of illegality,and legal consequences—the criteria for determining justifiable defense in these two fields of law should be properly differentiated.As a general principle,a"strictness in administrative law and leniency in criminal law"approach should be adopted.Specifically,the threshold for establishing justifiable defense under the Public Security Administration Punishments Law should be higher than that under China's criminal law with respect to conditions such as the origin of the threat,timing,subjective intent,and proportionality.Such differentiation does not constitute a departure from the unity of the legal order;rather,it is precisely the prerequisite and core means for achieving refined,scientific,and systematic coordination between administrative law and criminal law in China.After establishing the criteria for differentiation,coordinated models of application—such as"constituting excessive defense under administrative law while qualifying as justifiable defense under criminal law"—can be developed typologically.This approach can both activate the decriminalization function of justifiable defense provisions under criminal law and achieve reasonable regulation of defensive acts under administrative law,ultimately realizing the intrinsic harmony and unity of the legal order.
刊 名 现代法学 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 48(4)
分类号: DF611
机标分类号: D922.14 P542 TE121.3
在线出版日期: 2026年9月8日
基金项目: WJ2025A06:安徽省人民检察院检察理论研究课题重点项目,